Members of Gen Z, born between 1997 and 2012, say that social media ruined their childhood. Millennials, born between 1981 and 1996, complain that they cannot buy a house. Generation X, born between 1965 and 1980, moan that world is simply not interested in them, while Baby-boomers, born between 1946 and 1964, grouse that they face an uncertain retirement. Nobody in this world is happy with his or her life it seems.
PAKISTAN
(1)
President Ziaul Haq had ruled the country almost unchallenged as an autocrat for a long period of eleven years when his life was cut short by a plane crash on 19 August 1988. The next eleven years on the other hand, though heralding democracy in Pakistan, were remarkably tumultuous as this period saw four governments changing one after another, finally giving way to the third military dictatorship in 1999. Two brand new leaders, Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif, ruled the country as prime minister twice each, taking charge each time with great promise and fanfare, but seeing their governments dismissed much before completing their full terms for one reason or another.
Ziaul Haq was followed by Ghulam Ishaq Khan, who being Chairman of the Senate, took over as the country’s president in accordance with the 1973 Constitution. The Army, led by General Mirza Aslam Baig, correctly sensed the people’s mood who would not have taken kindly to a further extension of the military rule and decided to hold general elections in November 1988. President Ziaul Haq’s efforts to kill the party during his long rule had proved counterproductive and, in the election results, Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) led by the young Benazir Bhutto emerged as the party holding the largest number of seats. It won 94 out of the total 207 seats in the National Assembly.
Supporters of Ziaul Haq formed a nine-party electoral alliance, calling itself Islami Jamhoori Ittehad (IJI). The IJI came second in the elections securing 56 seats, reportedly helped by intelligence agencies. This marked the beginning of a decade-long two-party system shared between the left-wing PPP and the right-wing IJI and its successor the Pakistan Muslim League (Nawaz). Despite a clear demonstration in the elections of people’s will, President Ghulam Ishaq Khan was reluctant to hand over power to PPP naming Benazir Bhutto as the prime minister, and did so only when IJI failed to garner enough parliamentary support. She was also made to agree to two crucial conditions according to the writer Dennis Kux (The United States and Pakistan, 1947-2000): she would not interfere in promotions or other internal affairs of the military; and she would not involve herself too much in matters relating to Afghanistan or Pakistan’s nuclear program.
In another significant development which was to have a major impact on the country’s politics over the next twenty years, a party called Muhajir Qaumi Movement (MQM) representing the Urdu speaking people in Urban Sindh, emerged as the third largest party. Its popularity owed to discriminatory provincial laws setting down quotas for jobs and education favouring rural areas. MQM had chosen not to contest the elections directly but its members running as independents received 5.4% of the vote, winning 13 seats. It became part of the coalition formed by PPP in the Centre.
Benazir Bhutto finally became the first women prime minister in the Muslim word on 2 December 1988. She was already a world celebrity due to her long struggle against the military regime and enjoyed immensely popularity throughout the country.
There was a jubilant mood in the country that day with almost everybody eagerly looking forward to an era of democratic rule, free from the suffocating environment of the long military rule. I remember going for a drive with Tabana in the Clifton area in the evening. Streets were packed with cars and people moving at a snail’s pace and there was a carnival like atmosphere. Karachi people had voted overwhelmingly either for MQM or PPP, both parties had emerged victorious and there was hardly anybody not celebrating there. Every now and then somebody would raise a slogan, “Raaj karey gaa Muhajir.” (Muhajir will now be the ruler). There was electricity in the air that day and it was hard not to be deeply moved by the festivities or the joyous mood of the people.
After taking oath of office, Benazir promised to eradicate illiteracy, poverty, restore student unions, liberate political prisoners, provide equal rights to women and free the media. Her party however ran into political difficulties from the very beginning as the largest province Punjab had voted her political rival Nawaz Sharif, head of IJI, into power in the provincial elections. Nawaz decided that being Punjab’s Chief Minister gave him much more power than being the leader of opposition in the National Assembly, and used his position ruthlessly to obstruct federal government’s policies. The tri-party alliance of the President, the Army Chief and Nawaz Sharif made smooth governance in Islamabad almost impossible. The MQM too, under the patronizing hand of Army, broke its alliance with PPP less than a year later on 6 October 1989 which was a prelude to increasing violence and lawlessness in Sindh. The situation was not helped by strong rumours of Benazir’s husband, Asif Zardari, being involved in clandestine deals involving millions of rupees, earning him the title, Mr Ten Percent. There was also rampant mismanagement such as forced employment of thousands of incompetent party sympathisers in government owned organisations like PIA, steel mills and nationalized banks; and foreign policy blunders like divulging the names of Sikh separatist leaders of Khalistan movement to Indian prime minister Rajiv Gandhi though this was never proved. The PPP government was finally dismissed by President Ghulam Ishaq Khan on 6 August 1990 on charges of maladministration and corruption.
According to the American writer Stephen Cohen (The Idea of Pakistan), “Benazir was extremely intelligent, had strong contacts abroad (especially in the United States), and was the PPP’s undisputed leader. She also inherited two grudges – and grudges are as important in Pakistan as in any other state. One went back to 1972 when her father had nationalized the Ittefaq Foundry, the heart of the Sharif family’s industrial empire. This set the Sharif family against her, and their distrust was shared by the entire Pakistani business community. The second grudge was that of the army. Its people doubted her professional competence, were intensely suspicious of her since she was not part of the Establishment, and feared that she might seek revenge for her father’s death.”
It was now the turn of Nawaz Sharif to form the government. Elections held on 24 October 1990 saw IJI, a nine-party alliance headed by Nawaz Sharif, winning 111 of the 207 general seats while PPP and its allies managed only 44 seats. Soon after forming the government, Nawaz Sharif launched an aggressive program of economic liberalization and privatization. Import tariffs were drastically reduced to encourage industrial growth. At the same time, he started large infrastructure projects including Gwadar port and motorways linking Islamabad with Lahore and Peshawar.
Sindh during this time was ruled by a minority government headed by Jam Sadiq Ali, a thoroughly unscrupulous character, supported by equally power driven MQM. However, when the killings and mayhem in Karachi and Hyderabad assumed unacceptable proportions, the MQM was subjected by its allies to a harsh military operation bringing some peace to these cities.
Having a firm electoral base in Punjab, and a sizeable majority in the National Assembly, there was hope of IJI running a relatively stable government. President Ghulam Ishaq Khan had other ideas though and never allowed the democratically elected government to govern freely. Matters came to a head when Nawaz Sharif declared his intention to remove Eighth Amendment to the Constitution, which gave the president powers to dismiss government at will. In a pre-emptive action, the president then dismissed the government and dissolved National Assembly on 18 April 1993. However, an appeal to the Supreme Court quickly resulted in the restoration of parliament on 26 May. Despite the judicial rebuff, the president refused to step down. Relations between the prime minister and the president deteriorated to an extent where the army chief General Abdul Waheed Kakar had to step in, encouraging both to resign their offices on 18 July 1993.
Moeen Qureshi, a former Senior Vice President of the World Bank, was asked to become Caretaker Prime Minister. He launched a program of extensive reforms sponsored by International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank. The interim government devaluated Pakistani currency, increased prices of daily use commodities, targeted tax evaders and loan defaulters, and tried to broaden the tax base. It also issued orders to give complete autonomy to the State Bank of Pakistan
In the ensuing elections for the National Assembly held on 6 October 1993, Pakistan Muslim League (N) received majority of votes but PPP won the most seats, 89 against 73 of PML(N). Benazir’s position was further strengthened by a strong performance in the provincial elections enabling her to build a majority in Punjab also, the first time since 1971. The second Benazir Bhutto government was sworn in on 19 October. Asif Zardari, under detention since 1990, was called from the prison and made a minister.
This was a much stronger rule than her first term owing to greater experience in administration and civil-military affairs. The government launched 8th development plant to boost economic growth and announced Social Action Plan aiming to provide people with primary education, health, family planning and water. It also implemented a new energy policy to overcome chronic power shortages by negotiating deals with power suppliers; though these turned out later to be white elephants due to excessive financial incentives allowed to them, such as, dues payable in US dollars, full compensation for unutilized capacity and sovereign guarantees, etc. Benazir improved relations with United States removing the threat of being declared a terrorist state. After the passage of Brown Amendment, Pakistan started to receive financial and military aid and its frozen assets in America were ordered to be released.
At the same time, the government’s stability suffered from economic mismanagement, growing instances of ethno-sectarian violence in Karachi taking lives of hundreds of people, and conflicts with judiciary which later turned into a personal vendetta with the Chief Justice of Pakistan, Sajjad Ali Shah. Matters were exacerbated with the killing of the prime minister’s brother Murtaza Bhutto in Karachi in September 1996 in a police encounter. President Farooq Leghari, a PPP loyalist who had earlier been elected president with Benazir’s support, gradually got disillusioned with the deteriorating political and economic situation and instances of massive corruption. Confident of military support, the president dismissed the government of Benazir Bhutto on 5 November 1996. The fact that her government was about to fall was known to everybody that day (and announced by the Karachi evening newspapers in bold headlines), except Benazir who could not believe that her own protégé, Farooq Bhai, would ever “stab her in the back” and kept denying it to the very end.
In the words of author Hasan Askari Rizvi commenting on Benazir Bhutto’s second tenure, “She was more isolated than was the case when her first government was removed. Much of this can be explained with reference to her personalized style of rule, not being amenable to advice, political management through a group of cronies (most of whom were non-elected), and the interference of her husband in government affairs.”
————
SAEED
(2)
Relocating to a different city is a massive change in life. For Tabana, it was probably a welcome change after spending nearly twelve years away from her family who were now settled in Karachi. I was, on the other hand, a born and bred Lahori, and never having lived anywhere else except a few years in London, the move filled me with dread. Luck favoured us as usual and we never had to look for a house in Karachi. My job in ICI Polyester was to be taken over by my friend Ashraf Iqbal who was working at head office; he lived in a rented house in the Defence area and we could rent this place if we wanted.
Ashraf and his charming wife Mahnoor invited us for tea, serving delicious chocolate eclairs in their upstairs lounge. We saw the house and loved it. It was an almost brand- new construction with three spacious bed rooms, and being west-open (a term which I was to hear frequently in Karachi), was full of fresh air and sunshine. It had the added advantage of being only about seven- or eight minutes’ drive from my mother-in-law’s home. We agreed to take it immediately starting mid-March 1988.
There was a huge amount of packing to be done in Lahore as we had decided to move all our furniture to Karachi and rent this place out. This turned out to be a bad decision in the light of our experiences later but this was far away in future. The goods reached Karachi late in the evening, were unloaded supervised by one of my senior cousins visiting from India, Mian Bhai, and we were ready to start our life in a new city full of promise and excitement.
The next morning, after resetting some items of furniture and feeling thirsty, I opened the tap in the kitchen to have a quick glass of water. To my surprise, there was no water in the tap. I thought that this must be due to some local blockage and tried other taps in the house but again, no water. I now panicked and telephoned my brother-in-law, Mansoor Bhai to report this highly unexpected disaster. I received my second surprise of the day which turned into a shock when Mansoor Bhai appeared to treat it casually, saying that this must be due to lack of water in the overhead tank. This was a new term for me and on enquiring what this meant, I was told that I must also check my underground water tank and, while I was doing this, the water pump too. These strange sounding words baffled me; in Lahore we had a metered water connection with running fresh water available direct from the pipeline 24 hours of the day. When I checked, the water pump appeared to be dead and another call to Mansoor Bhai elicited the information that I would have to get a plumber from Delhi Colony to fix the machine, and a water tanker from somewhere to fill the tank. I was scrambling up a steep learning curve on the subject of living a life in Defence, Karachi.
Other surprises were to follow. The front lawn, if one could call a barren sandy piece of land without a blade of grass a lawn, was an eyesore, and the sand blanketed our furniture day and night. Tabana took up this challenge with her usual zeal, and in less than a year the desert was turned into a lush green lawn surrounded on all sides by flowery plants. When she showed me a tiny three-inch piece of stem telling me that after she had planted it, this would grow into a huge plant climbing over the walls, l could hardly believe her. But sure enough, bougainvillaea would soon become a beautiful sight in our home with red and purple flowers decorating an entire corner of our lawn.
We had been living there hardly for three months, when an army of oversized black ants suddenly invaded our home. There were thousands of them blanketing the front porch and driveway. I had no idea where they had come from or why. They probably had a home in the barren lawn and watering the ground forced them to come out of the ground. There were so many of them that stepping out in the porch they were crushed under our feet making a crunchy sound. After checking around, I was advised to sprinkle DDT along all the outer walls. This worked and we would soon see thousands of dead ants lying on the ground in the morning. The horde disappeared after two or three days and we heaved a sigh of relief.
The next bug to attack us was cockroaches. In Lahore, we put pesticides in gutters of the house periodically and usually a few cockroaches were seen crawling out. Following the same procedure in our new house however proved to be a terrifying experience. As soon as a little powder was poured into a hole in the kitchen, cockroaches began to rush out of the hole, first a few, then a dozen, and then hundreds. Cockroaches are normally crawling insects but some of this lot started to buzz all over kitchen and we had to cover ourselves with towels. Wave after wave of them emerged from their deep hole to replace their slain brethren, some of them displaying air power. As we started to swat them, the floor of the kitchen and the sideway got covered with dead cockroaches and it took almost an hour of relentless battle to exterminate their last valiant soldier. It seemed that our house had for a long time been a safe haven for all kinds of creeping species and our moving there had upset their comfortable way of life.
But once the initial teething problems had been sorted out and we began to settle in in our new abode, the house was a delight to live in. Enjoying the cool sea breeze in the evenings was an entirely new experience for us coming from Lahore and was extremely refreshing. The house was an architectural beauty with bright, spacious bedrooms and comfortable sitting areas. Soon we started to receive a constant stream of visitors; my two sisters Tazeen and Nageen were settled in Karachi as were Tabana’s mother and two brothers, not counting an army of cousins scattered all over the town. We started to entertain on a regular basis and played host to many guests, including my father and mother visiting from Lahore in summer. Our home became a convenient location for arranging and hosting guests for outstation weddings.
ICI had a beautiful beach hut at Hawksbay and in the summer of 1988 when my parents were visiting us, we decided to arrange a family picnic there. It was a villa type double storey hut with two bedrooms, lounge, dining alcove and a spacious covered terrace facing the beach. Checking around whether they would like to participate, almost everybody in our extended family responded with a resounding ‘yes’. The numbers started to balloon and I went to see our admin czar Khawaja Saqib to find out about the facilities available at the hut including cutlery and crockery. He answered my query with his characteristic aplomb, declaring that I did not have to worry about the crockery at all. “You can,” said he,” entertain any number of guests at the hut easily. You can invite eight, ten or even twelve guests without any problem.” I had in my hand a list of sixty confirmed invitees at that time and more were being added every minute. I kept mum, thanked him for the info and came back; it was a given that the company crockery cabinet must be kept securely locked and shut during our stay at the hut.
We ended up with seventy-four people and the picnic was a massive success with everybody thoroughly enjoying the day out. Even senior citizens like my father and my uncle Sajid Hasan had their share of relaxation reclining in the bedroom, which had a clear view of the beach. We had arranged a biryani lunch while some families also contributed with their own share of food. As usual, I spent most of my time sitting in the water thoroughly soaked. Soon it was time to go and by the time everybody left, the hut was a complete mess littered with mud and food left overs. With assistance from our own domestic help, we cleaned up everything making sure that things were left in more or less the same condition as before, and said good bye to the ICI hut dead tired.
The next few years could be called the era of weddings, when marriages of some of our close family members took place quickly one after another. My third sister Ambreen tied the knot in Summer 1989 followed by the youngest sister Tamkeen two years later in June 1991. Much to my dismay, living in Karachi meant that I could hardly contribute anything to the arrangements for these marriages but my parents, supported now by my younger brother Naveed, ensured that things were manged like clockwork. Two years later, in the winter of 1993, our home in Karachi was the venue for the marriage of my cousin Rashid. We played host to his parents, who had come from Lahore for this purpose, as well as my own parents, and made all the arrangements for the numerous functions held to celebrate the wedding. A few months later, the process was repeated for the marriage ceremony of Naveed which took place in March 1994 and was the source of great joy and happiness for all of us. Our home played host next year to hold a grand dinner celebrating the Nikah of my nephew Shahab (son of Tabana’s elder brother, Zamir Bhai) who had come from the United States for this purpose. Shahid, younger brother of Rashid, now decided to join the festivities and his wedding two years later was also arranged by us, being an exact replica of the one for Rashid.
———-
(3)
At the head office, I took over from my dear friend Azhar Malik as Corporate Finance Manager, being responsible for all group level financial functions. This was the second time I had taken over from Azhar who had moved over from the Polyester finance manager’s job three years earlier handing over to me. Azhar was moving now to ICI Malaysia from where he would go to work at the ICI head office in London, coming back to become first the finance director and then the chairman & chief executive of ICI Pakistan. An extremely promising career tragically came to an end only a year and a half later when, having gone for an evening walk at Aunty Park in Clifton, he suffered a massive heart attack in the car on his way back and breathed his last minutes after that. He left me truly heart broken. Azhar was a sterling character, modest and unassuming, with a sparkling sense of humour. He was always extremely popular with whatever team of people he was working with, who loved to work for him. At the same time, he was cutting in his one-liners about the people who did not come up to his standards. He was one of the rare characters who combined razor sharp intelligence with extreme hard work, which was the reason he rose rapidly through the ranks and became head of the company at a young age.
After reporting to my new office, the first thing serenely explained to me by Azhar as part of my ‘taking over’ was the need to quickly rush to the card room to play bridge during our lunch time. He along with a couple of office colleagues similarly inclined, would reach the canteen a few minutes before the opening time and stand patiently outside waiting for the doors to open. Being his ‘disciple’, I had to join them though a little embarrassed at the school boyishness of this routine. We rushed through our lunch as quickly as possible and would then start playing cards until it was time to reluctantly move back to the office.
Life in every headquarter is very different from working in the field, be it military, civil service or a company. Policy is made here and there is an illusion of power; though it comes at the expense of independence. You have much wider authority over juniors working at far flung geographical locations but, at the same time, you are at the beck and call of your superiors literally twenty-four hours every day. Priorities change with the speed of lightning and one is always chasing moving targets. Office politics can be killing and one has to tread very carefully over minefields.
At the same time, working at head office has its own rewards especially if you are lucky to have competent and understanding bosses, as I was. Both M.F. Khawaja, general manager finance, who retired after a year and a half and S.K. Mehdi who replaced him, were thorough professionals and old hands in ICI. Though poles apart in personality, one a laid-back theoretician and the other a restless dynamo, they knew their jobs and I got on very well with them. There was also constant interface with the chairman, Naseem Mirza, deputy chairman Sana Qureshi and board director Dr Mahmood Saeed, who were all great leaders and very supportive. There was a remarkably informal atmosphere at the top level allowing free discussion and even harsh criticism at times, which reflected their self-confidence and maturity. Guests who came to have lunch with directors at the office canteen were sometimes amazed at the type of humorous comments and one-liners we were exchanging at the table which they said was unthinkable in their offices. I loved the company of Dr Saeed especially who would have his first cup of tea early in the morning with me every day in my office before starting work.
Mirza Sb called me one day in his office saying that he was getting seriously concerned about our annual financial results being leaked in the market every year before their official announcement. ICI Pakistan was the largest public company listed on the stock exchange and its shares were the subject of heavy speculative trading on the exchange. Possession of confidential information relating to company profits would give a huge advantage to a share broker and millions of rupees could be gained or lost by dishonest traders through illegal trading of stocks. Mirza Sb made me responsible for finding the leak.
Starting to plan for this task, this was a kind of mission impossible; financial results were received at the head office from divisions spread all over Pakistan, consolidated, and then sent to the press for printing of annual reports for circulation to thousands of shareholders. Hundreds of people were involved in this process from beginning to end and the leak could take place at any stage in the process. This was pre-computer period and all the work was done manually; the concept of data encryption had not yet evolved. The only way we could think of to identify the source of leakage was to somehow release dummy figures to whoever was leaking the information (called a poison pill), and then see what happens. To play a game of bluff in other words. I quickly came up with a way to do this.
We prepared an accounting adjustment, which was to create a financial provision for a presumed loss, at the head office. The adjustment (poison pill) was large enough to make a significant impact on the company’s profits. One of the divisions was then instructed to incorporate this adjustment in their accounts. Accounting packages were received from divisions, consolidated by the accounting team, and then handed over in strict confidence to a senior typist to type out the set of accounts.
Alarm bells starting ringing at this moment. The Chairman called me over saying that he had again received a call from a trusted source announcing leakage of our ‘confidential’ income figure. To my delight, the figure given to him matched exactly with the ‘bluff’ income appearing in our consolidated accounts. Suspicion zeroed in on the typist and subsequent investigations proved that he was indeed the source of leakage. The typist in question was a senior company employee in his fifties who had been with ICI for many years and well respected for his maturity and competence. There might have been genuine family or other constraints which had forced him to indulge is such questionable behaviour, but he was nonetheless dismissed. This turned out to be the last time the company faced the embarrassment of its profit figures being leaked to the stock market.
There was never a dull moment in the head office, as the saying goes. With so many bosses around, there was a flurry of activity going on all the time. I was sitting with Qureshi Sb one morning in his office discussing some matters when he suddenly blurted out the remark, “Saeed, I am very happy with you.” Knowing his highly developed sense of humour, I was sure that he was referring to some blunder that I had made and asked him if this was the case. He repeated his comment saying, “No, No, I am very happy with you.” Getting even more concerned, I asked him seriously what he meant by this. He told me that he was getting a lot of calls from banks these days and they all seemed extremely annoyed with me. “As long as I am receiving complaints” he continued, “I know that you are doing a good job. It is only when they start complimenting you that I shall start getting worried.”
The banks had a good reason being angry with me. They had been taking advantage of ICI for a long time charging high mark-up rates for the loans and overdraft facilities we had with them. We had sixteen banks in our portfolio at that time, almost every major commercial bank in Pakistan, doing substantial business with the company and thus commanded a high leverage. Soon after coming to the head office, I found that that this leverage had not been translated into an advantage for us, rather the banks were charging us simply the market rates or rates even higher than the market. I took this matter up with senior officials of various banks and demanded that they lower their rates by as much as three or four percentage points to equal a benchmark rate that we considered appropriate for a company of our size and financial standing. The banks did not like this at all but eventually agreed to match the benchmark rate, resulting in considerable increase in profits for the company. They were charging high rates simply because they could get away with it; they had not been challenged but once they were, they did not put much of a fight.
———
(4)
It had been years since I had last seen Anisur Rahman, my ex-boss at ICI Paints in Lahore in the early eighties. He had retired from ICI a couple of years ago and had joined a British multinational company, J&P Coats as its MD. A friend of mine I met in a hotel by chance one day in early summer 1991 told me that Anis Sb’s mother had passed away a few days ago and there would be a reading of Quran for her at his home the same evening. I thought I must go there to offer my condolences in view of our past relationship. Little did I know that this small gesture of mine would prove to be a milestone in my life and change it for ever.
As people started to leave after the reading, Anis Sb took me aside and said that he would like to see me privately whenever I had the time. He did not tell me what it was about but hinted that it was important. I went to meet him a few days later at his home in the evening. He started by telling me all about JP Coats which manufactured various kinds of domestic and industrial threads and about its regional head, a Turkish gentleman called Meric (pronounced as Merich) Ulgen, who he said was a fireball of a person who had transformed the region’s size and profitability and its operations in Pakistan. I was surprised to learn that one of its products was the famous Anchor brand embroidery thread, recalling that my mother had always insisted on buying Anchor brand threads for her embroidery because of its high quality and longer lasting colours. Anis then tossed a question casually whether I would like to join the company as its finance director. I told him that I was quite happy working at ICI and had never considered leaving the group. He said that I should still give it a thought and added that he had arranged to me to visit Istanbul to meet Meric Ulgen. I could not say no to this offer.
Tickets were arranged hurriedly for me and I reached the airport. This was the most hush-hush travel that I had ever undertaken; nobody at my office knew about it of course, nor did any of my friends. I had no idea that in order to protect this secrecy, I would have to weave a tangled tale of lies waiting for my flight in the Karachi airport executive lounge. As I was sitting there sipping my drink and waiting for my flight to be announced, in walked a friend working at another multinational company and asked me where I was heading for. I told him that I was going to London for a company meeting, which was fine as ICI was a British company. After a few minutes another friend arrived who I found was going to London too. This forced me to amend my story a bit; I was now flying to Rome first and take up a connecting London flight from there. I was dreading the arrival of yet another friend when thankfully my flight was announced and I boarded the plane.
While I was waiting in the executive lounge, I saw three Japanese gentlemen seated in an alcove near me sipping their drinks. In walked the head of a big Pakistani car and motorcycles manufacturing group in casual dress and started talking to them. This went on for about an hour after which he left the way he had arrived. I realized that for the elite of this country, walking in and out of high-security international airport lounges was no different from visiting a local restaurant.
A month after my trip to Istanbul, I was again called by Anis Sb and this time he made me an offer to join the company. I now started to think seriously about a change which was going to be a big one because it involved moving from one of the biggest and most prestigious companies in the country to a small, one factory outfit. Tabana left the decision to me, as did my parents, saying that only I could evaluate the facts and the circumstances underpinning the move. After giving this a lot of thought, I finally decided to call it a day at ICI though I had been associated with the company for twelve happy and eventful years. It was a remarkably friendly and amicable parting. The farewell function held on the last working day was attended by almost everybody working at head office including all directors. I stayed at my office working until late in the night to wrap up things and ensure a smooth handing over to my successor, Feroz Rizvi.
The incumbent finance director at JP Coats, Ahmad Sahib, was an extremely competent and hardworking person in his late fifties and, as I found out later, a kind person and a thorough gentleman. However, for some reason I never knew, his and Anis’s stars did not match and there was a strong feeling of antipathy between the two of them. How strong it was, I came to realize only when I was told by Anis that it had been planned for me to join the company not at its office in Karachi, but at its regional office in Turkey. I was to spend one month at Coats factory in the historic city of Bursa for induction and training in September. I requested Anis that as it was a longish period of time, Tabana should be allowed to accompany me, to which he readily agreed.
A company car picked us up at the Istanbul airport for the scenic journey to Bursa, which included a short ferry ride crossing the sea of Marmara. Our destination was an apartment situated near the city centre which served as the company guest house. We had a good-sized bedroom allotted to us and there was a common sitting and dining area. The apartment was looked after by a handsome Bulgarian, in his mid-thirties, who was the house keeper as well as the cook serving breakfast, lunch and dinner. It was an extremely cosy setting and we soon made ourselves comfortable there. Turkish cuisine is traditionally very tasteful and wholesome with many types of kebabs, such as shish doner or Iskender kebabs being part of almost every meal. Fresh vegetables are always served as starter, liberally mixed with olive oil and lemon.
Bursa is a city associated with a lot of history, much like Lahore. It was the first major capital of the Ottoman empire and has many historical buildings dotted around the city. It is famous for its silk trade and thermal springs and is an industrial centre of the country. We found the Turkish people incredibly hospitable, especially after knowing that we were from Pakistan. They would immediately respond with saying alhamdulillah, Muslim and try to make themselves as helpful as possible. Language was an issue because hardly anybody could speak English, but the language barrier disappeared by their spontaneous warmth. Tabana loved to walk around the city centre on her own especially the narrow lanes of Bursa’s famous covered bazaar, where her nicely tailored Pakistani dress made her look distinct even in a crowd.
I wanted to buy a pair of shoelaces once, but wandering around the small lanes of the main market in Bursa, couldn’t find it anywhere. Finally, at one of the shops after I managed to communicate to the shopkeeper what I wanted by showing him my shoelaces, he said he didn’t have them but instantly called a small boy of about ten and said something to him in Turkish. The boy motioned me to follow him, and then started walking going from one lane to another at some speed. After about three minutes of brisk walk, he stopped in front of a shop and triumphantly pointed out something in the shop. I did find shoelaces there, of various types and colours, hanging from a bar like one would hang a necktie. Before I could thank him, the boy left and disappeared in the crowd.
The regional finance director, who I was associated with was a Brit, Simon Greenwood, who helped me a lot with my induction. He invited us for lunch at their home on a Sunday introducing us to his charming wife Anna and their two kids. Their house was situated on a hill having a panoramic view of the city and the rooms were built at multiple levels. Years later when we were building our own house in Karachi, Tabana instructed our architect to follow the same theme, the front portion of our home also has multiple levels reminding us of our time in Bursa. On most weekends, we went for long drives out of the city through the beautiful country side. There were green orchards and small, charming houses dotted along the roads. Unlike Istanbul and Bursa, where women usually wore western dresses, most of the women in the countryside were clad in the traditional long robes and seen working in the fields or driving horse carts, going about their chores.
One of things which impressed us in Turkey was the way a section was provided in every mosque for women to offer their prayers. There were specially designated areas at the back of prayer hall, enclosed by waist high wooden fences, where women could go and offer prayers. There was also a supply of head scarves available for their use. I saw many women offering prayers there, especially on Fridays.
A month passed with me having to learn all kinds of processes involved in the manufacture of threads, its supply chain and its accounting. We reluctantly said good bye to our Bulgarian host and reached the airport to board a plane for Istanbul. It was a shock however when we saw the aircraft; it was a tiny plane with hardly half a dozen seats for passengers and it was difficult to imagine how it could ever take off. Having seated ourselves, it was quite unnerving in the beginning but things settled down once it took to the air and managed to carry us safely to Istanbul in about half an hour.
Istanbul was as beautiful and charming as everybody who has been there knows it to be. In the short time that we had, we went to see The Blue Mosque, Sophia Grand Mosque and Top Kapi Palace Museum, which had a breath-taking replica of the royal Ottoman era harem. The Grand Bazar Covered Market stood up to its reputation for brisk bargaining but was a treasure trove for typical Turkish metal and glass decoration pieces. We had a most interesting boat ride on the Sea of Bosporus; the boat travels between the two continents of Asia and Europe, alternately touching a port in Asia, then in Europe, back to Asia and so on. This is the kind of boat ride which cannot be found in any other place in the world.
Anisur Rahman and his wife Nargis Rahman had joined us in Istanbul and we did some shopping together. On our last night, Meric took us and some other Coats managers for dinner at a famous hotel. We reached there at about 8:00 p.m. and were seated at a round table containing ten to twelve chairs. The dining area was actually a huge hall with about fifty tables and a large dancing floor. Meric ordered food and we started dinner with Turkish delicacies. There was soft music in the background and after about an hour a few couples started to dance. The music now became lounder and was distinctly Spanish which was no wonder because majority of guests in the dining hall were Spanish; Turkey is a favourite destination for Spanish tourists. In the meantime, our dinner was continuing at a leisurely pace with course after course enlivened by drinks. The Spanish couples on the dance floor seemed to be thoroughly enjoying themselves and presented some beautiful dances. Time passed quickly and it was almost midnight when it was time to leave. We left Istanbul the next day for Karachi carrying with us a lot of sweet memories of this wonderland of Turkey and its beautiful people.
———
(5)
Joining JP Coats finally in Karachi, I was in for a surprise when Anis told me that Ahmad Sahib would not be retiring before 31 December which was still three months away. This was a kind of déjà vu, reminding me of ICI, where I was hired full six months before the job was ready for me. I asked him what I was supposed to do in the meantime, to which he had a ready answer. I was to ‘restructure’ the salary system of the company to make it tax efficient, meaning that it should be designed to result in maximum tax savings, both for the company and the employees. The job was simple and straight forward but there was just one catch, it required massive number of calculations possible only by a computer while I was a total illiterate as far as computers were concerned.
Computers had actually begun to be used by businesses as early as late seventies though their incredibly high cost made them prohibitive for purchase for most organisations except the very large ones. The first computer to arrive in ICI, IBM Mainframe 360, became operational in early eighties; this was a massive structure occupying two big rooms at our head office in West Wharf – consisting of dozens of discs of plastic tape slowly and noiselessly running on spools, housed in six feet tall steel cabinets. One of the first applications to be transferred to computer in ICI was the employees’ salaries. This being a highly confidential stuff demanded the highest possible secrecy. Though access to the computer room was strictly controlled, this was not considered sufficient. Our salaries manager, Mr Rafiq, an elderly soft-spoken gentleman, was seen inputting the data in the computer every month covered by a big black cloth from head to toe; he was not allowed to remove the black shroud until he had finished the job.
As time passed and computer technology began to develop at a furious pace, the mainframes were first replaced by so called ‘dumb terminals’ connected to the mainframes, and then by ‘intelligent terminals’, equipped with software and capable of independent operations. I had one such computer placed in my room by my boss S.K. Mehdi despite my protests because I abhorred them, as an inducement for me to start working on computers. To his disappointment, all I had learnt about this computer by the time I left ICI was how to put it on and how to turn it off.
Computers now had the last laugh; I was left with no choice but to somehow come to grips with Lotus123, the spreadsheet application in general use in those days (later replaced by Excel) if I had any chance of completing the salary restructuring exercise. I had been a provided a desk in a corner of the office in an alcove seating the MD’s secretary which was next to the desk of my own secretary Francesca. During negotiations for the terms of my job, I had insisted on having a secretary of my own which was a novelty in this company because till now the MD was the only person to have a secretary. I, on the other hand, could not imagine life without one because the nature of a finance manager’s job demands confidentiality and trust, and I had always had a secretary at each of my jobs in ICI. This proved to be a blessing for me, far more than I had realized earlier, because Francesca was well versed in computer programs like Lotus 123 or WordPerfect, the leading word processor application in those days, and started life in JP Coats as my coach and teacher. I distinctly remember the first day when I asked her if there was a simple way to add certain figures I had typed in the computer and she told me that yes, there was indeed a formula I could use to add figures. I was overjoyed when after applying the formula, the computer produced a figure for the addition, as if by magic.
I was working in my office a few days later when I received a phone call from Mr Saleem Khan, an ex-director of ICI, who was now managing a recruitment agency. He had invited me for lunch at his office about six months earlier while I was still in ICI to vet me as a possible candidate for any job they might have in the future and the matter had ended there. I was surprised to hear from him now. He asked me to call him to discuss a confidential matter and, when I did so, told me that a German multinational company in chemicals business was ready to offer me a job as finance director of their Pakistan subsidiary in Karachi. I told him immediately that while I was thankful to him for the offer, I had now joined JP Coats and, regardless of the terms, it would not be proper for me to change jobs. Mr Saleem Khan was not happy with my response but accepted it when I remained firm in my view.
My report on employees’ salary restructuring was ready by the time I was to take over my job as finance director. The strange decision not to allow me any interface with my predecessor meant that I did not have the benefit of a smooth handing over/taking over which is the normal practice on assuming any new job. My learning process was made incredibly easier however by the meticulous and detailed records maintained by Ahmad Sb for all kinds of activities. I was amazed, for example, to see his working papers for preparation of monthly accounts of the company, all done in pencil in long hand and accurate to the last decimal, the work of a super human being it seemed. Thanks to Francesca, I was by now well versed in Lotus 123 able to apply all kinds of complex formulas and quickly began the task of converting Ahmad Sb’s workings to Lotus 123. When the job was completed the financial statements of the company, which previously took nearly three days to prepare, could now be produced within an hour of the closing of accounts.
All was not smooth sailing however. Soon after starting work at my new place, I began to develop a strong home sickness for ICI. For all the must-do-urgently commands from multiple bosses, tough deadlines and the rat race in my old job, one could not beat the company’s glamour and charm. I had not realized that moving from a very large firm to a small firm would mean a massive culture change. I missed my team in ICI, all top- quality managers, possessing style and class. Matters were not helped by the abundant free time I had at my disposal now that the initial learning phase was completed. Digitalization of accounting and payroll systems had saved an immense amount of time, leaving me free to brood over the past. I also rued my decision not to join the German chemicals company when I had the offer in my hand. During this period, I suffered from typhoid once and malaria twice and was getting really frustrated with the recurring bouts of very high fever. This was a low point in my career but, unknown to me, fate had other designs ready in store for me. It turned out later that joining JP Coats at this juncture was the best decision anybody could have made considering the rest of my life curve.
A finance director has one great advantage over other divisional managers, those heading marketing, supply chain, human resource or manufacturing: direct access to board members and other most senior people in the hierarchy. Chief financial officers attend board meetings to present financial results of the company at least once a year and, for publicly listed companies, once every quarter. They also have frequent meetings with top officials like regional or global heads along with the country head to report on important matters and have the opportunity to develop fruitful relationships with them. I had first met the regional head Meric Ulgen in Istanbul during my introductory visit there and then continued to see him off and on in Turkey or during his frequent visits to Karachi.
I found Meric a fascinating personality, like a character in a business studies textbook. He was of medium height and build, but extremely agile and energetic. Unlike many people in position of power, he did not talk much but when he did, he commanded attention. He was a chain smoker consuming nearly four packs a day. But the most striking feature of his personality was his capacity for extreme hard work. He would arrive at his office usually before 7:30 in the morning and continue to work until or sometime well past dinner. He had a spacious apartment in Istanbul where his family lived, but he himself spent five days a week staying at the Bursa factory in a small apartment built on top of the administrative offices. He was known to have transformed JP Coats operations in Bursa from being a small factory to one of the biggest manufacturing units in the group. He became a legend in the Coats Group and perhaps the best tribute to him was paid by our Group chief at a dinner in London honouring him on his retirement, “Meric, how can we make you younger?”
He had a rough side to his personality too. Being a hardworking and competent person, he expected his subordinates to be the same, and reacted harshly when people did not. In office meetings in Bursa, he was known to dress people down and even hit them with a piece of chalk in his hand when offended. He would fire people, some of them old colleagues, without a second thought the moment they lost their utility. For some reason, a mystery to me, he began to like me soon after I joined the company. He even asked Anis for me to be transferred to Istanbul but Anis did not agree. With hindsight, I think that it was me being a straight talker, sharing my views with him without fear or hesitation even when disagreeing with him, that appealed to his primitive nature. Acting this way was part of my nature but to him, with experience of the sort of people around him, this was perhaps a novelty. This has in fact been my experience with many such people; those generally held in awe or fear and who nobody dares to cross, in fact feel happier or at least easy with people who do challenge them and deal with them on somewhat equal terms.
He took a liking to Tabana as well, partly because he seemed to appreciate her decision to join me in Bursa for a month during my training. We got to know him fairly well there. He was also probably impressed with her simple and modest style and the way she could talk to him without fear or inhibition which he must have found unusual. He visited our home many times in Karachi and was always very relaxed and acted in a somewhat fatherly fashion with us.
I soon settled comfortably into my new job, thanks to Anis who was an ardent believer in the art of delegation. He hardly ever interfered in his team members’ work as long as the job was being done satisfactorily and this suited my style perfectly. In fact, the lack of it was the main reason which had led me to leave ICI. The company’s office was very conveniently located at the city centre, I.I. Chundrigar Road, less than fifteen minutes’ drive from my home. I could now have lunch daily at my home, as I used to do in Lahore, though it was quite rushed. “During lunch time”, my mother once remarked in her typical dry humour, “Saeed offers his prayers like a hurricane, eats his lunch like a hurricane, and takes a nap like a hurricane.” All in all, I was much more relaxed and peaceful in this job than I had been for many years.
Time in JP Coats passed quickly and it was now the summer of 1996. I was called one day by Anisur Rahman to his room. After some preliminaries he told me that he was going to retire from the company in September of next year and it had been decided that I was to take over his responsibilities as the managing director and chief executive of the company with effect from 1st October. I looked at him and was momentarily lost for words. Though it had always been at the back of my mind that Anis would retire someday and I may be considered as his successor, I hadn’t foreseen it to happen so soon. I thanked him in suitable words for placing his trust in me and hoped that I would come up to the high standards expected by Meric which was not an easy task. My appointment was announced to the company staff next month at the company’s annual function when, incidentally, I was in Lahore for my father’s chehlum, a day marking the conclusion of forty days after his death the previous month.
———-
(6)
Back in the summer of 1988, my father had enjoyed the beach picnic at Hawksbay thoroughly. He and my uncle, with my mother being there occasionally, had spent the day relaxing in their exclusive room facing the beach in the ICI hut talking about everything under the sun, including recalling verses from Urdu poetry. Being a very active person throughout his life, he was always keen to participate in outdoor events and enjoyed the company of people whenever he had the opportunity to do so. He had an extended circle of friends in Samanabad many of whom used to come to our house regularly in the evenings to have sittings and cups of tea. Having lived all my life in Lahore, this was the first time my parents had come to our home to live with us and it was a very pleasant experience, especially with my sisters visiting us regularly. Being an elder person in the family, one would have understood if he expected others to come and pay him visits at our home but this was not his style. He made sure that we go to see all our relatives including nieces and nephews even if they lived far away, and made the visits thoroughly enjoyable by his lively company, telling jokes and funny anecdotes. Though we wanted my parents to stay longer, they left after a few weeks’ stay as he wanted to get back home and start his normal life.
He came to stay with us again after about a couple of years but this time he had come alone and my mother stayed back in Lahore. He said that now being fully retired from work, he was bored in Lahore and wanted a change of scene. We welcomed him and were hoping to have him with us for at least a month. Though otherwise normal, he appeared to be a bit restless. I was surprised when after only a week or so, he asked me to book him a seat for return journey to Lahore. I tried to persuade him to stay a bit longer but he wouldn’t change his mind and boarded the plane for Lahore after staying for a few more days. I didn’t know it then but he was showing the initial stages of dementia which would get progressively worse with passage of time, later developing into the dreaded Alzheimer’s disease. It would in the end rob us totally of his lively and vibrant personality, or really the person we knew lovingly as abbu.
In the spring of 1994, my parents came to Karachi for Naveed’s wedding. My father participated fully in the wedding ceremonies and seemed to be enjoying the festivities though a bit detached and not his usual self as a person in control of events; that role was taken over by my mother. But still, he was attentive and warm towards family members coming to visit him and talk to him, conversing in a jolly manner.
We took him to see a renowned neuro physician in Karachi. After some tests he confirmed what we already knew and prescribed some medications. My mother was sitting next to my father and the doctor asked him who she was. After considering this for a few moments, my father answered promptly, “She is my secretary. You know she is very efficient. She does all my work and she is a great help to me.” My mother listened quietly with the same expressionless face she always had. Nobody could detect what was going through her mind at this time. By this time, she would have surely been experiencing the vagaries of my father’s behaviour twenty-four hours a day, his eccentricities and his unpredictable demands; or the lack of any response for the people caring for him. All this must have been the daily life of my mother but she never allowed it to worry us and chose to bear all this on her own, at least not me during my visits to Lahore.
Nearly a year passed. It was a Friday afternoon early February and this being the off day in those days, I was reclining in my bed reading a book when the telephone rang in the lounge. I thought it was my mother ringing back because a few hours earlier I had telephoned her for a general chit chat. We talked about this and that and putting the phone down, I asked her casually about how she was feeling. She said that she was more or less fine. I got a little concerned about the way she said more or less and asked for more details. She said she had been feeling a bit restless since Wednesday and she had already booked an appointment with her consultant cardiologist for the next day. With these words the conversation had ended. I heard Tabana pick up the phone next door, her voice sounding extremely agitated and then saw her rushing to me speechless. I went to the lounge and picked up the handset. It was one of my cousins in Lahore at the other end. He told me without any preamble that it was bad news and that my mother had died of heart attack a few minutes ago. I did not quite comprehend what was being said and turned back to Tabana for her to try to make some sense out of it. She was equally incredulous saying that the news must be about my father and not mother. We phoned back but received confirmation that it was indeed my mother who had passed away. She had taken an afternoon nap and getting up about an hour ago, asked my sister Tamkeen who is a doctor and was visiting from her home in Islamabad, to make her a cup of tea and having said this she went to the washroom. She did not return for some time and after my sister went to look for her, was found unconscious lying on the floor there. She was taken to the hospital immediately by Naveed where she was pronounced dead upon arrival. She had turned seventy-one in September of the previous year and had lived a remarkably healthy and active life. She had always prayed for her life to end quickly without suffering from any prolonged illness and her prayers had been answered.
There was little time for grieving as we had to get to Lahore the same evening. As the news spread, more and more people wanted to go to Lahore for the funeral and eventually there was a list of nearly twenty people planning to leave. I rushed to the airport to get plane tickets and, with incredible luck, managed to book all the seats on the PIA flight scheduled to depart only a couple of hours later. Things were happening like in a bad dream and we packed our things and got to the airport in a trance. As we boarded the plane, the sun was setting in the West casting a gloomy red glow all around us. We reached Lahore two hours later and took taxis home. My mother was resting in her bed peacefully like she had just gone to sleep.
The next day, as the funeral procession started from our home towards the graveyard, it started raining. The rain steadily became worse. I became extremely worried about water getting into the open grave and my mother entering her final abode in a wet coffin. I began praying earnestly for the rain to stop, prayers increasing in intensity as we neared our destination. Miraculously, the rain stopped the moment we reached the graveyard. The proceedings went on smoothly including the final sermon traditionally delivered with the mourners standing some distance away from the grave. The rain waited patiently and then, as soon as we started walking towards our vehicles, started to come down heavily as if trying to make up for lost time.
Even in the state that he was in, my father seemed to be devasted by her death. He had always called my mother ‘Barri Bi’. On the last day when my mother had become unconscious and Naveed was carrying her in his arms to the car, my father held her hand and said, “Barri Bi, don’t worry, you will be all right.” Later, after she was brought home, Naveed sat down with him in the lawn and he asked where Barri Bi was. Naveed was momentarily lost for words but then with some difficulty told him that she had passed away. My father didn’t seem to listen saying that she would have been injured falling down and the doctor had put a bandage on her head. Naveed again told him that she had died and that her body was lying in the drawing room.
My father then looked at him for the first-time eyeball to eyeball for a long time. He then put both his hands on his walking stick and placed his forehead on his hands looking down. In that position he whispered, “Has the doctor given up?” Naveed couldn’t say anything for a long time, and then said, “Yes Abbu.” After sometime he looked up again and said, “Allah malik” (it was Allah’s will), and Naveed saw tears on his cheeks. He was looking extremely vulnerable then.
After a few weeks, my father came to live with us in Karachi. For the first time, we realized what it was like to care for an Alzheimer’s patient. My father was not a temperamental or irritable person and mostly kept to himself, but he had reached a stage where even simple tasks sometimes presented a challenge for him. He retained his strong personality talking to us in his usual confident manner but was now living as much in Karachi as in his childhood city of Jaunpur. He did not recognize me as his son though he would still talk to the guests visiting him in a cordial and entertaining manner. After a couple of months, he appeared to be yearning to go back to his own home and moved to Lahore to live with Naveed, who did a heroic job taking care of him day and night like nobody else could. He was much happy there and led as normal a life as he possibly could.
Things seemed to be settling down when next summer he unfortunately slipped in the bathroom fracturing his thigh. Hearing this, I immediately took a plane to Lahore. He was a strong-willed person possessing abundant courage and normally this would not have been a big issue for him, but for a patient in his condition it was a different story. Though obviously feeling pain, he had only a vague idea of what had happened to him.
The surgery was successful but a blood clot formed in the leg post-surgery travelling slowly in the veins towards the heart. It reached its destination exactly after a week and caused myocardial infarction. He passed away peacefully early morning and moved to the other world. He did not change his routine; this was the same time he used to get up and leave home cheerfully every morning for his long walk. Only this time he had gone for a walk to a place far away never to return.
———
PAKISTAN
(7)
General elections were held 3 February 1997. Unlike the 1990 elections when Nawaz Sharif had won among allegations of rigging, this time he benefited from multiple factors fatally jeopardizing PPP’s prospects. Caretaker prime minister Meraj Khalid, one of the founders of PPP and immensely popular in the masses, spoke frequently in favour of accountability and against corruption, indirectly targeting PPP. Supreme Court Chief Justice Sajjad Ali Shah held the action of President Leghari in dismissing Benazir’s government legally valid, and chose to announce his judgement just four days before the elections swaying public opinion against PPP; this was probably a countermove by him in the ongoing vendetta between him and Benazir. In another move against PPP, the caretaker government allowed a BBC film, “The Princess and the Playboy” to be run on TV just before the elections. The film depicted alleged corruption by Benazir and Asif Zardari and further alienated PPP’s voters.
When the election results were announced, PML(N) returned with a massive 135 seats out of the total 217 seats of the National Assembly. PPP managed to get only 18 seats losing as many as 71 seats and, for the first time, failed to win any seats in Punjab. Nawaz Sharif took the oath of office on 18 February. PMLN installed Chief Ministers in Punjab, Sindh, and NWFP, while an ally BNP took charge in Baluchistan. In his first address to the people, Nawaz called it a ‘heavy mandate’, repeating it ad nauseam until it became a public joke. With the benefit of hindsight, it might be said with some degree of truth that ‘heavy mandate’ went to his head and led him to take many politically incorrect, even reckless actions, hastening his downfall in less than three years.
Soon after taking office, 13th Amendment to the Constitution was passed on 1st April 1997 doing away with the powers of president to dismiss the government, to dissolve assemblies (introduced by President Zia) or to appoint chiefs of the army, navy and air force. Thereafter, 14th Amendment was passed giving the leader of parliamentary party power to cancel the membership of a member of his party on voting against the party-line in the assembly, closing the doors on floor crossing. Benazir Bhutto, equally wary of dismissal of her government by two ruthless presidents one after the other, supported Nawaz in passing these amendments.
Nawaz Sharif became increasingly aggressive, aiming to bring the president, the parliament, the judiciary and the military all under his control. Like his predecessor, he too started a feud with the Chief Justice, Sajjad Ali Shah. This time it was on the question of appointing five additional judges by the Chief Justice which Nawaz opposed fearing that they might vote against him. Matters reached a point where Nawaz, facing a contempt of court notice issued by the CJ, had a bill passed in the parliament aiming to trim his powers, but President Leghari refused to sign the bill. This in turn led to the government starting impeachment proceedings against the president. Leghari decided to tender his resignation and retired Justice Rafiq Tarar, a Nawaz nominee, became the new president. Supreme Court judges had by now been disillusioned by the autocratic style of Sajjad Ali Shah and forced him to resign as well. This completed Nawaz’s control over both the presidency and the judiciary.
Turning his attention to the ex-prime minister now, an accountability cell was set up targeting Benazir Bhutto and Asif Zardari. Benazir chose self-exile while Asif Zardari, arrested on the day of dismissal of Benazir’s government, continued to remain in jail. He was to remain in prison on charges of corruption and murder until freed in 2004 completing nearly eleven years behind bars, though he was never convicted. There was thus no effective opposition left in the country to act as a check on Nawaz’s powers.
The government launched many schemes to improve the state of the economy. An ambitious scheme was launched calling for donations from common people to a fund created specially to reduce the foreign debt burden of the country. People donated generously, including minor children, but it hardly made a dent in the size of the debt. Mega development projects were launched like Islamabad Lahore motorway. Trade with India was liberalised.
A seismic event in India-Pakistan relations happened when India tested an atomic bomb on 11 May 1998. Nawaz Sharif came under intense pressure from the general public to follow suit. President Clinton tried to dissuade him from doing so offering substantial financial and military aid but despite facing intense international pressure, Pakistan too tested its atomic bomb on 28 May 1998. As expected, U.S. and other western countries immediately imposed strict economic sanctions on the country. Finance Minister Ishaq Dar in a panic move froze all foreign currency accounts, an ill-considered action, because it evaporated overnight foreign investors’ confidence in the long-term stability and resilience of Pakistan’s economy. Despite tough economic conditions however, riding on the wave of popularity after the nuclear tests this was the pinnacle of Nawaz’s tenure as prime minister. He had everything one could have ever wanted but he wanted more. Intoxicated with his popularity and political power, he started to commit a series of blunders which eventually culminated in his downfall in less than eighteen months.
The 15th Amendment Bill was tabled in the National Assembly by PMLN in August 1998. The purpose of this bill ostensibly was to impose sharia (Islamic law) in the country, masking the real intention of making Nawaz Sharif the all-powerful amir-al-momineen (commander of the faithful). The Senate however refused to pass the bill and Nawaz was made to wait until the next Senate elections to gain the required majority. This started to ring alarm bells among people, especially the army high command, about Nawaz’s growing autocratic tendencies.
In October 1998, the army chief General Jehangir Karamat delivered a speech at the Naval College in which he advocated setting up a National Security Council which would give a constitutional role to the military in policy making. There was nothing new in this proposal which had been discussed off and on since the days of Ziaul Haq. Nawaz seized this opportunity however, to assert his power over the military and ordered the army chief to resign. General Karamat, being a professional soldier, duly resigned just a few months before his retirement. This action, considered by some to be Nawaz’s most serious blunder, became highly unpopular among the military cadres. The next army Chief was General Pervez Musharraf who was appointed by the prime minister bypassing two senior generals.
Nawaz’s unchallenged power did however pay a dividend; it allowed him to extend an arm of friendship towards India. This would have been difficult to try in ordinary circumstances, and almost unthinkable for Benazir Bhutto, given the Establishment’s perennial suspicion about her liberalism. Indian and Pakistani prime ministers had a chance to meet at a SAARC conference in Colombo and agreed to reduce tension between the two countries. Atal Bihari Vajpayee, the Indian prime minister, crossed Wagah border on a “friendship bus” to come to Lahore in February 1999. The visit culminated in signing a Lahore Declaration on 21 February 1999 pledging both countries to avoid accidental use of nuclear weapons by implementing nuclear safeguards, to intensify efforts to resolve the Kashmir dispute and to enhance bilateral dialogue. The treaty was quickly ratified by the parliaments of two countries.
The army chief, General Pervez Musharraf, however had other ideas. He, along with a few trusted generals, made a plan in May 1999 to capture some strategic heights in the snow covered Kargil district of Ladakh, part of the Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir, ostensibly to cut off the Indian military supply line. Though initially successful, the Indian army quickly regrouped and managed to recapture most of the lost areas. The two-month-long conflict claimed the lives of thousands of soldiers on both sides bringing both nations close to a full-scale war and possible nuclear face-off. The Lahore Declaration was now dead.
Sensing the dangers involved in further escalation of conflict, Nawaz Sharif arranged a meeting with the US President Bill Clinton on 4 July to obtain support from the United States to cease hostilities. Clinton lectured Nawaz on the futility of its military adventure, complained about lack of Pakistan’s support in its war against Al-Qaida and chided him about his ignorance of Pakistan’s nuclear arms having been redeployed during the war without his knowledge. Pakistan agreed to withdraw all forces from Indian territory as part of settlement. Clinton would later reveal in his autobiography that “Sharif’s moves were perplexing” since the Indian Prime Minister had travelled to Lahore to promote bilateral talks aimed at resolving the Kashmir problem and “by crossing the Line of Control, Pakistan had wrecked the [bilateral] talks”.
Nawaz returned from Washington thoroughly shaken. He ordered General Musharraf to identify the culprits behind the Kargil fiasco and to take action against them. Army, on the other hand, blamed Nawaz for agreeing to the unconditional withdrawal of forces from Kargil. There was also a dispute between politicians and army generals whether, and to what extent, Nawaz was briefed about the full implications of Kargil plan. Intriguingly, far from General Musharraf being held responsible for wrecking the Lahore Declaration, he was promoted as Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee by Nawaz in September 1999 in addition to his being the Army chief. This however failed to remove the growing distrust between the two. According to American author Brian Cloughley (A History of the Pakistan Army), core commanders had by this time resolved that if Nawaz acted in any way against the military interests, the army will take over the prime minister house and other strategic locations in a pre-emptive move. Things were fast moving towards a final showdown.
Nawaz Sharif now made a plan to find a way to send Musharraf abroad and to remove him as army chief in his absence. He found an opportunity soon and persuaded Musharraf to go to Sri Lanka to attend a conference there. While he was there, Nawaz appointed his trusted Director General I.S.I, Ziauddin Butt, as the army chief and announced this decision on TV. At the same time, he issued orders that the plane in which Musharraf was returning back home, should not be allowed to land anywhere in Pakistan. Karachi airport was barricaded to prevent any plane from making a landing. This was a naive decision by any standards as it jeopardized the life of not only Musharraf but all the passengers on that plane, and this came as a shock later to even his closest aides like his brother Shahbaz Sharif, Chief Minister Punjab, or Nisar Ali Khan, the home minister. The only person he confided in was the journalist Nazir Naji who was accompanying him on a plane journey back to Islamabad that morning. Nawaz showed him a rough draft of his TV speech which stunned him. Naji tried to dissuade him but Nawaz’s mind was made up by this time. This proved to be the last order issued by Nawaz Sharif as prime minister.
Army reacted swiftly after the TV speech. Troops raided and took over control of the prime minister house, TV headquarters and other sensitive buildings. Core Commander Karachi took over control of Karachi airport. Nawaz Sharif was arrested along with most of the cabinet ministers. He was later tried on the charge of hijacking Musharraf’s plane and sentenced to life imprisonment. President Clinton and the Saudi king intervened on his behalf and he agreed to be exiled to Saudi Arabia along with his family, signing an undertaking not to return home for the next ten years. He would spend the next eight years abroad, returning to Pakistan in November 2007, largely due to the efforts of a Lebanese politician Saad Hariri.
“Nawaz Sharif talked about democracy,” wrote Lawrence Ziring, the political scientist and author (Pakistan at the Crosscurrent of History), “but his administration was more like a Mughal court. Nawaz ignored the conventions of cabinet government: he neither held cabinet meetings nor made cabinet decisions. Surrounded by family members and a few close associates, Sharif’s actions were more in tune with absolute monarchy than with representative government.”
———–
(8)
Ishrat Husain, the noted Pakistani economist, had called the period from 1988 to 1999 in Pakistan as ‘the lost decade’. Nearly all the social and economic indicators relative to countries with similar per capita income suffered a decline during this period. Economic growth fell down to 4.7 percent per year compared to a respectable 6.3 percent in the previous decade. A major cause of this was a sharp decline in industrial growth, down to 5.1% from 8.1%, resulting in higher unemployment and increase in level of poverty which doubled from 18% to 34% during the decade.
Pakistan’s economy had grown at a fairly impressive rate of 6 per cent per year through the first four decades of the nation’s existence. In spite of rapid population growth during this period, per capita incomes doubled, inflation remained low and poverty declined from 46% down to 18% by late 1980’s. This healthy economic performance was maintained through several wars and successive civilian and military governments in the first forty years, until the decade of 1990’s reversed this trend.
This was all the more disappointing because the people of Pakistan had heralded the dawn of democracy in 1988 with great fanfare and high hopes. Gone were the days of suffocating military rule with a strong religious bias, a government which had remained preoccupied with the war in Afghanistan and to keep itself in power. The economy was ripe for a take-off to transform it from low-income to middle-income group of countries. People looked forward to policies favouring social welfare in areas like education, health, housing and food. These hopes were to be dashed with a stunning brutality.
It is quite possible that Benazir Bhutto, during her first tenure (1988-1990), was greatly hampered by the very limited field of action allowed to her by President Ghulam Ishaq Khan and army chief, General Mirza Aslam Baig. Most of her time during this period was spent in warding off aggressive moves by Nawaz Sharif as the Chief Minister Punjab aided by the establishment.
Nawaz Sharif, on the other hand, acted swiftly and decisively on assuming power in 1990. As narrated by Ishrat Husain (Governing the Ungovernable), he “took some very bold steps to liberalize, deregulate, and privatize the economy. His government abolished the greatly misused import-licensing system, deregulated investment controls, liberalized the foreign exchange regime, and privatized several industrial units and two nationalized commercial banks, marking the beginning of a new economic era. The foresight, courage and determination showed by him in steering and shepherding these extremely deep-rooted reforms have remained unparalleled.”
Unfortunately, however, the reforms failed to achieve the desired results because his government was soon dismissed by President Ghulam Ishaq Khan in a clash of egos with the prime minister. Benazir Bhutto took up the helm of affairs again in 1993 and while she did not reverse the reforms, there was no strong follow through either. She remained too preoccupied with keeping her government afloat to give serious thought to economic reforms or to formulate an alternative economic vision for the country. Investment and exports stagnated or declined throughout this decade. Inflation remained well above 10%. Nawaz Sharif too did not show much interest in introducing structural improvement in the economy in his second tenure. Stung by his sudden dismissal four years ago in 1993 and energised by the ‘heavy mandate’, he was now totally absorbed in consolidating his political power through a series of constitutional amendments; economy could wait until he became the all-powerful amir-al-momineen.
Ishrat Husain had concluded, “It was [. . ..] frequent changes in the government throughout the 1990’s and the consequent political instability it created that played havoc with the economy. Uncertainty and discontinuity of economic policies, patronage based economic governance benefiting a small elite to the exclusion of the majority of the population, and exogenous shocks …. derailed the economy. The investment ratio plummeted, and persistent fiscal and current account deficits led to an accumulation of large, unsustainable domestic and external debt throughout the decade. The ratio of debt-servicing vis-à-vis foreign exchange earnings reached almost a level of 40 per cent. The freezing of foreign currency accounts of residents and non-residents in the aftermath of the 1998 nuclear tests eroded investor and business confidence in the economy.”
——–
Leave a Reply