Chapter 8 Fifties
FIFTIES
“They were able to reveal their more authentic selves in a whole new way. And, of course that’s what writing memoir requires: a willingness to look at one’s failures as well as one’s victories, and then make sense of them.” Joyce Maynard, best selling author of 18 book, meeting her classmates at a 50-year school reunion.
PAKISTAN
(1)
General Pervez Musharraf, chief of army staff and chairman joint chief of staff committee, took over reins of power of the country when he ousted the Nawaz Sharif government on 12 October 1999. Earlier, his plane bringing him back from Colombo after attending Sri Lankan army’s 50th anniversary celebrations had been denied permission to land in Karachi by air traffic controllers on orders issued by the prime minister’s office. Musharraf finally got down from the plane after a long agonizing wait in the air when the control tower was surrounded by army troops. He was constantly talking to his subordinate generals in Karachi and Islamabad relaying minute to minute developments on the ground but there were still times when he thought it was touch and go. Careful take-over plans, developed by the high command much earlier to deal with just such an eventuality, proved their worth and army took over prime minister house, TV station and other strategic buildings in a smooth, bloodless coup. The nearly three years reign of Nawaz Sharif was over.
History on this day repeated itself and like the two previous army coups, in 1958 by Ayub Khan and in 1977 by Ziaul Haq, people generally welcomed the change in government. Almost all political and religious parties as well as the media supported the military takeover. They loved democracy and had greeted it enthusiastically in 1988, but had become exasperated by too frequent changes in government, four in the past eleven years, leading to lack of governance, corruption and instability. People were also deeply apprehensive about Nawaz Sharif’s increasingly autocratic tendencies, planning to implement sharia rule in the country and declaring himself as the all-powerful amir-al-momineen (commander of the faithful). PPP, the main opposition party which had been victimized with many of its leaders including Asif Zardari put behind bars and Benazir Bhutto choosing to leave the country, was not too unhappy about the change in government. The two other main political parties, MQM in Sindh and ANP in NWFP, were also disillusioned and had stopped supporting MLN. There were no spontaneous public demonstrations in the streets against the military coup and life went on peacefully as before.
After declaring a state of emergency and suspending the constitution, Musharraf styled himself as the country’s chief executive rather than chief martial law administrator. He tried to introduce an aura of ‘enlightenment’ in the country by presenting himself as an ‘enlightened leader’ in sharp contrast to the Islamic fundamentalist rule of Ziaul Haq. This idea, though long overdue, was however received by people as a state doctrine imposed from above and failed to find much traction amongst the deeply religious masses. With over-use and over-emphasis, it became a kind of satirical catch word often used in the media to ridicule Musharraf’s policies.
Like all military rulers before him, Musharraf though enjoying his life being a dictator craved for political legitimacy too. In this, he received an unexpected helping hand from the Supreme Court of Pakistan, headed by Chief Justice Irshad Hasan Khan. After judges were forced to take a fresh oath under the Provisional Constitution Order (PCO), the court in a landmark decision delivered in May 2000 not only declared the assumption of power by him as legitimate under the ‘doctrine of necessity’, it gave him the power to make changes to constitution of Pakistan as and when necessary. This was however conditional upon holding a general election in the country by 12 October 2002.
In order to give his presidency a legal cover, a referendum was held in the country in April 2002 asking the voters whether they were happy to have Musharraf continue as president for the next five years, effectively extending his term without holding an election. According to the announced results of a manifestly rigged process, 98% of people were said to have voted for him. Many observers believed that holding the referendum was a tactical mistake by Musharraf because it helped to muddy his hitherto clean image of an honest, no-nonsense soldier, and made him look much like the crafty politicians he was claiming to rid the country of. President Rafiq Tarar, who had continued in his office after the change of government, resigned in July 2001 and Musharraf took over as president. In August 2002, he issued the Legal Framework Order making numerous amendments to the constitution which gave wide powers to the president like dissolving the national assembly and control over key appointments.
The elections mandated by the Supreme Court were duly held in October 2022. Political engineering by the government succeeded in creating a new party, Pakistan Muslim League (Quaid e Azam), consisting mostly of renegade MLN members. At the same time, religious parties were encouraged to come together to form Muttahida Majlis- e-Amal (MMA). When the results were announced, PMLQ won the highest number of national assembly seats (118) out of total 342, with PPP getting 81, MMA 60, MLN 19 and MQM 17. PPP dominated in terms of popular vote percentage despite Benazir Bhutto being in exile. At the provincial level, PPP was the dominant party in Sindh, PMLQ in Punjab, and MMA in NWFP and Baluchistan. After some political give and take, PMLQ managed to form the government in the Centre with help from MQM but only after about a dozen PPP members agreed to change loyalties. Zafarullah Jamali of PMLQ took oath as prime minister.
MMA joined with PMLQ later to pass 17th Amendment to the Constitution which gave a constitutional cover to the Legal Framework Order. Musharraf further consolidated his powers in January 2004 when he was given a vote of confidence by the senate, national assembly, and all four provincial assemblies. His dream of achieving political legitimacy was now complete, at least in his eyes. His personal choice, Shaukat Aziz, a technocrat and former banker, replaced Jamali as prime minister of Pakistan in August 2004. He was now well secure in his power but, like his many predecessors was not content, decided to overplay his hand, and started to run into politically turbulent waters in less than three years.
----------
(2)
While all this was happening in Pakistan, an epoch-making event had taken place seven thousand miles away which not only changed the course of history for that region but for almost the entire world. It had a profound and lasting impact on Pakistan as well. For Musharraf it proved to be a godsend, much like the Russian invasion of Afghanistan and the ensuing Afghan war twenty years ago had proved to be a bonanza for military dictator Ziaul Haq.
A series of four coordinated suicide attacks were carried out by a group of Arab young men in the United States of America on the morning of 11 September, 2001. Nineteen hijackers seized control of four commercial airplanes flying from East Coast airports to California and the tragic events took place rapidly in the next 90 minutes. Two planes were deliberately crashed into the Twin Towers in Lower Manhattan. The first plane struck the North Tower at 8:46 a.m., followed by a second plane striking the South Tower 17 minutes later. The impacts and subsequent fires caused both 110-story towers to collapse within two hours. A third plane was flown into the western side of the Pentagon (headquarters of the U.S. Department of Defense) at 9:37 a.m. The impact resulted in a fire and partial collapse of the building. The fourth plane crashed into an empty field in rural Pennsylvania at 10:03 a.m. after its passengers and crew members learned of the other attacks via mobile phones and fought back against the hijackers. Nearly 3000 people lost their lives in these tragic events.
The U.S. almost immediately launched a War on Terrorism. The militant organization Al-Qaeda was held responsible for planning and financing the attacks and U.S. decided to invade Afghanistan in October 2001, after the ruling Taliban government refused American demands to extradite Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden. The Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan after the 1988 Geneva Accord had led to various Mujahedin warlords fighting each other and the resulting civil war was one of the most brutal phases in the history of this country. By 1994, the warlords had divided the country among themselves letting lose a reign of terror over their subjects. Taliban, literally meaning students of Islamic schools, emerged as a direct result of these oppressive and appalling conditions. They took up arms against the warlords and riding on people’s support first captured Kandahar in 1994, followed by Herat in 1995 and Kabul in 1996.
Pakistan found itself in the crosshairs of America’s fury because of its deep and long association with Taliban. Pakistan army had, according to the noted author Ahmed Rashid (Descent into Chaos), “backed the Taliban and encouraged thousands of Pakistani youngsters to find and die for Taliban.” According to him, “Afghanistan had become an incubator for Al-Qaeda, but so had . . . . . . Pakistan, because of the nexus between Islamic extremists and the army, both of which tolerated an Al-Qaeda presence before 9/11.”
At the time of 9/11 attacks, General Mahmood, the chief of ISI, found himself in Washington DC attending intelligence meetings with senior American officials. Mahmood was ushered the next day into a meeting with the deputy secretary of state Richard Armitage who was in an angry mood. He was not prepared to listen to anything and gave Mahmood no choice: “You are either 100 per cent with us or 100 per cent against us.” As the Pakistani delegation was leaving, a US official startled Mahmood by swearing that a discussion was going on regarding the possible use of nuclear weapons on a target probably in Afghanistan. Mahmood reported somberly to Musharraf that Armitage had threatened to bomb Pakistan “back into the Stone Age” if they sided with the terrorists (though Armitage later denied having said this).
Bob Woodward, the noted American journalist has vividly described the events of those days in his book, “Bush at War”. Secretary of State Colin Powel had advised President Bush that no action by them could be successful without the help of Pakistan and they had to be taken on board. Bush ordered Powell to deal with this as best as he could. A list of seven demand was then prepared and put before Pakistan. These included providing logistics and intelligence facilities to U.S. and stopping supplies to Afghanistan, and breaking all kinds of relations with Taliban government. Powel then telephoned Musharraf to say that America wanted Pakistan’s help in the war. Expecting some tough negotiations, he was greatly surprised to be told by Musharraf that Pakistan would accept all seven demands and would support the U.S. fully in its war efforts. Many economists were of the view that Pakistan should have bargained for some strategic concessions at this time including waiver of its substantial foreign currency loans. Musharraf was perhaps playing a long game and would be rewarded handsomely for his cooperation in the days to come.
A Pakistani delegation led by General Mahmood went to Kandahar on 16 September to try to convince Mullah Omar either to hand over Osama bin Laden to International Court of Justice or to extradite him, and close down all terrorist camps. Mullah Omar rejected all these demands. Soon after this, United States launched an attack on Afghanistan on 7 October 2001. At the same time, Northern Alliance, a coalition of Afghan forces opposed to Taliban comprising Tajik troops led by Ahmad Shah Masud, Herat’s Ismail Khan, Hazara’s of Central Afghanistan and Uzbek forces under General Rashid Dostum, began their advance towards Kabul. Taliban forces abandoned Kabul on 13 November and surrendered Kandahar, their seat of power, on 27 November. Taliban leadership fled to the countryside while Osama bin Laden managed to escape, taking refuge first in Tora Bora cave complex in the mountain range of eastern Afghanistan and then incognito in Abbottabad where he was eventually tracked and killed by U.S. forces in 2011.
The war brought immense destruction to Afghanistan and thousands of civilians including women and children were killed during the hostilities. Pakistan also had to pay a heavy price on account of mounting terrorist attacks launched from Afghan territories. Thousands of Pakistani armed men who were fighting alongside Taliban in Afghanistan found a safe haven in the tribal areas of Pakistan and started terrorist activities, including suicide attacks against police, armed forces as well as civilians. Uncountable number of lives were lost and thousands of families were displaced from their homes. The violence, though controlled to some extent through military operations, continues to this day in one form or another.
In the immediate aftermath of the war, however, there was massive Western support for Pakistan. As Rashid recalls, “Aid flowed to Pakistan from all quarters, especially from the United States. On September 23, 2001 Bush had waived all sanctions against Pakistan [imposed after nuclear tests in 1998] and asked Congress to reschedule repayment of $379 million in earlier loans and give a fresh loan to $597 million and a cash grant to $50 million.” Similar financial assistance was sanctioned by European Union and Japan. In return, the U.S. led Coalition forces were granted all kinds of logistics support and use of sea ports and air bases. The quick collapse of Taliban would not have been possible without the huge support provided by Pakistan to the Coalition forces.
--------
SAEED
(3)
It was the summer of 1997 and I was sitting with my MD, Anisur Rahman, in his office one day, when he casually mentioned that property prices in the Defence area in Karachi were experiencing a slump these days and it was a good time to buy. Normally, this kind of comment would have come and gone and one would hardly give it a second thought. However, this time, it got me thinking. We were living in a rented house in Defence now for nine years and though it was a nicely built place, comfortable and conveniently located, maybe it was time now for us to move to a place of our own. After moving to Karachi from Lahore in 1988 and for at least four or five years after that, I had never given a thought to building a house here because a thought was always at the back of my mind that we would someday be returning to Lahore to live in our own canal-side townhouse residence in Muslim Town. Times had changed now; I had a secure job at JP Coats with its office in Karachi, my parents were no longer with us unfortunately which had always been a strong inclination for me to return and, perhaps the most important point, we were now fully settled in this city and thoroughly immersed in its day-to-day life.
The thought of building a new house on a plot of land seemed to us not only difficult but almost impossible considering how busy I was in my job. We therefore started looking for a house, either a freshly built one or preferably an oldish place which could be improved by some extra expenditure. There were dozens of houses available for sale and we started spending most of our evenings in the distasteful company of property dealers. This was a specie of its own kind, fiercely competitive and, with a few exceptions, not burdened with any morals or principles. They would promise to show you dozens of houses ready for sale but when you actually showed an interest, the house would mysteriously be found to have already been sold, and at a price much above your range. In time, we not only came to recognize these tactics, Tabana became an expert in beating the property dealers in their own game by bluff and counter bluff. One of their favorite ploys was to tell a buyer that a meeting had been fixed with a non-existent seller, simply to impress the buyer. They usually got away with this because most buyers shied away from the meeting for one reason or the other. Tabana, on the other hand, immediately said yes to the meeting knowing that it was a ruse, putting the property dealer on the defensive.
We particularly fell in love with one house situated on A Street in Phase 5. It was an old, simply built house but had a huge lawn attached to it which was its main attraction. An offer was made to the seller matching his demand and we eagerly waited for it to be accepted. To our acute disappointment however, the seller decided to sell it to another party. It was heart breaking news and we felt really bad about it. What we didn’t know however, was that this was an extremely lucky break for us. Mansoor Bhai, Tabana’s elder brother who happened to be an experienced civil engineer, now entered the picture and convinced us that, rather than buying an old house and spending lots of money on renovation, it would be far better for us to build our own house made exactly according to our requirements and specifications. What clinched the deal was his offer to manage and supervise the construction himself as he was relatively free in those days.
Our search now moved from houses to plots. We found one exactly to our liking soon which fitted my budget too. An advance was paid to the plot owner, a Sindhi landlord, binding both parties to the contract and we met after a month in the property dealer’s office to finalize the deal. To my surprise however, the owner appeared somewhat reluctant to proceed and after a pause revealed that he had received a higher offer for the plot. I knew that I could enforce the agreement legally but could not bring myself to forcing the gentleman to suffer a loss on my account. I told him that I was releasing him from the contract and he was free to do whatever he thought best. I am not sure what happened next; he appeared to discuss this with his companion for a few minutes and then came back to us saying that he would go ahead with the deal after all.
The Defence Housing Authority (DHA) transfer deed was signed on the last day of the year, 31 December, legally transferring the ownership of property. We engaged a renowned architect to draw up plans for the building specifying only two requirements of ours: plenty of light and plenty of air. After about a dozen drafts followed by long discussions, he did a marvelous job and produced plans for a stylish looking house which met our requirements. What we didn’t foresee however, was that we would soon be making drastic changes to these drawings during the course of construction making it an entirely new plan altogether.
After a lengthy process of approval of plans by DHA, construction started in early summer. Hardly a month had passed when a major problem confronted us out of the blue. A routine inspection carried out by a DHA inspector revealed that the passage between the main building and the boundary wall which should have been 10 feet wide was actually six inches short. By this time, two stories had been erected. The inspector ordered us to pull down the building as it had been erected contravening the approved plans. The news came as a huge blow and I had to put a stop to the ongoing construction. I was lucky however to know the Secretary DHA, one of their top officials, personally. He was a retired colonel of great charm and character, and I took an appointment to see him at his home. He received me cordially and after listening to me remarked that this was not a problem, rather it was an ‘irritation’. He immediately issued instructions to the relevant officer to impose a penalty which was a few thousand rupees, regularizing the matter. This was another example in my life when, just when it seemed that I had hit a brick wall and all was gloom and doom, a person emerged from somewhere and miraculously lent me a helping hand.
Construction went on smoothly after that and while the civil structure was completed in three months, finishing, plumbing, electrical and woodwork took another nine months or so. Mansoor Bhai, true to his words, was present on-site day and night supervising all this work, having his lunch on-site too brought by Itrat Bhabhi from his home. He put his heart and soul in the project. He used to go to the market personally and spend hours there to procure the best quality of building materials available such as wood, marble, plumbing or electrical fittings. The wood, for example, used for doors and cabinets in our home is without a single blemish or dark patch which is a rarity according to expert carpenters.
Mansoor Bhai had a unique style of managing his staff. Construction workers are usually extremely tough and hardworking but notorious for their bad temper. It was amazing how easily and confidently he managed to control these workers even though he would sometimes lose his temper and be extremely harsh with them. His hold over them was not just due to his tough attitude or even mastery over his field of work, but something else altogether, he had charisma.
He had his own team of workers, fiercely devoted to him, who had served him over many years and went to work for him from job to job. I had a chat once with the head carpenter Waheed. He told me that he had actually stopped doing building work and had started his own small business in the town of Haripur, about a hundred miles north of Islamabad. However, one day he said, he received a message from Mansoor sahib asking him to join him for an urgent business. He packed up his business, he said, and started the long journey to Karachi to join his ex-boss. This is called charisma.
All was not smooth sailing, however. There were frequent arguments between Mansoor Bhai and Tabana over design or choice of materials, sometimes heated. Tabana’s views were guided mainly by aesthetics while Mansoor Bhai was naturally more interested in durability and toughness. For example, for the front lawn, Tabana wanted it to gradually slope downwards in all directions towards the boundary walls; while Mansoor Bhai preferred it the other way round, sloping from the boundary walls towards the center, and his reason was simply that he wanted to protect the boundary walls from water seepage. Tabana won the argument.
The front portion of our home has split levels inspired by our time in Bursa, Turkey where houses on the surrounding hills have rooms built at split levels. During construction, we went to see dozens of houses in DHA in various stages of construction or finished but unoccupied. We took lots of ideas from these houses which we could put to good use in our home. Early on for example, we found that the size of attached bathrooms in most houses was about double the size we had in our plans, and quickly changed the size of our bathrooms wherever we could. In Finishing also, each house had something of its own to offer. The theme for the front courtyard was borrowed by us from Agha Khan Hospital, terracotta stone walls as well as terracotta floor tiles.
Finally, the house was declared ready and we moved in on 1 October 1999. The first surprise to hit us was the realization that it was too big! This was natural because the area of our new home was double the size of the previous house, and it took a lot more walking to go from one place to the other. This took some time getting used to. The next worrying thing was the errors that we began to notice with our planning and design of the house almost as soon as we stepped in there; there were too many things that could have been done this way or another, and why didn’t we think about it earlier. Talking about it to other people revealed however that this was a malady common to all new house builders and would soon be cured.
Mansoor Bhai seemed well pleased with his creation and, after receiving a rousing thumbs up from all types of visitors to the house, declared with his customary modesty: “Allah ne meri izzat rakh li” (Allah has protected my honor).
----------
(4)
JP Coats had a fairly large set up in India, operating there since early twentieth century. I was invited in August 2000 to attend a regional conference being held there in the South Indian city of Bangalore where the company’s head office was situated. Tabana was also keen to visit India and as it was a business trip, I contacted the commercial attaché at the Indian High Commission in Islamabad for guidance. He was extremely courteous and asked me to come and see him at the High Commission to get the two visas. I did so on a rainy morning, he greeted me with a cup of coffee, and our two passports were stamped with Indian visa while I was having a pleasant chat with him. He told me that, as a special favor, we had been exempted from reporting at a police station immediately on landing in an Indian city and then daily afterwards which was the usual requirement. Indian visas restricted Pakistani visitors to visit only three Indian cities which I had named as Mumbai, Bangalore and Chennai.
The whole process took about half an hour and I was feeling quite happy. Trouble however, awaited me outside. As soon as I came out of the High Commission building, a man dressed in a shabby shalwar suit approached me. He started to ask me questions about who I was and what was I doing inside the Indian High Commission. It was raining heavily; I was wet and I lost my temper telling him to get lost. He then disclosed that he was a member of Intelligence Services and threatened me with not only cancellation of visas but also confiscation of my passport. I came down to earth immediately apologizing for my rude behavior and told him that I had behaved so only because I thought he was an Indian secret agent. I said to him that I held all government servants in high regard and saluted his devotion to duty working in such harsh conditions. He cooled down and allowed me to go.
We boarded a PIA flight to Mumbai feeling excited but with some trepidation as to what it would be like being in the country of our forefathers. A country we had heard so much about from our elders who had lived there, or seen it in the romantic films we had been watching since our childhood. A country both extremely close to us in culture, language and geography yet so far in political relations. What awaited us there however was something we had not imagined in our wildest dreams and so strange that one would not have believed it if it hadn’t been my own experience.
Approaching the airport looking out of the windows, one could see tens of thousands of slum housings shacks (called kholi) spread out on either side of the airport for miles which was an awe-inspiring sight. Coming down from the plane, we entered the airport building which, in marked contrast to the modern Karachi airport, looked like an old warehouse. As we started to join the queues for immigration check, we heard a man shouting, “All Pakistanis in that corner, all Pakistanis in that corner”, pointing towards his left. Surprised, we looked in that direction and found people making a queue towards a man sitting in a glass cabin there. Tabana and I joined that line slowly moving towards the counter and reaching there, forwarded our two passports to the man. He looked at me and in a very harsh voice, said in Hindi, “Why are you giving me two passports?” I told him that the second passport was my wife’s. The man continuing in the same tone instructed me to give him only one passport. He examined it and then handed the passport back to me with a form which he said was to be completed in quadruplicate (original plus three copies). Tabana received the same treatment.
It was a long form asking all sorts of details regarding the purpose of visit, dates and addresses, etc. As soon as I completed filling in the forms and was ready to move, I was approached by four or five people begging me to complete their forms as well because they were illiterate and could not do it themselves. Looking at their expectant faces, and knowing that they were all Pakistanis, there was no way I could refuse and took their forms. By the time we were ready for the immigration desk again, the hall was almost empty. We stood at the red waiting line until I was told to move to the counter. The immigration officer asked me a few questions talking in Hindi and then moved a stamp and a stamp pad towards me. He told me to start stamping the quadruplicate form. He would point his finger at a given space, order me to stamp it, move his finger to another space, order me to stamp that, and so on. After every few entries he would tell me to press the stamp on the stamp pad. Each page required three or four stamps and so this bizarre performance took quite some time. He then stamped the passport himself but ordered me to fill in the three blank spaces in the triangular entry stamp; date of entry, R.P. Number and Sticker Number (whatever these meant) in my own handwriting. He was not addressing me as ‘aap’ which is the usual expression in Hindi/Urdu for you, but as ‘tum’ which is informal and reserved either for close friends or somebody junior or inferior. I was wearing a dark business suit with tie and for all practical purposes must have looked like a decent, respectable person. May be for this reason, I have never felt so humiliated as I did at that time stamping paper after paper under orders barked at me from behind the counter. Tabana followed me at the counter and had to go through the same procedure.
Getting out of the airport, we found a taxi and took a short ride to the terminal for the local flight to Bangalore. A company car was waiting for us at Bangalore airport which took us to our hotel. We were looking forward to spending four pleasant days there and enjoy our first visit to India where there was so much to see. Fate had however kept something else in store for us which would change everything. The next day being a Sunday, we hired a rickshaw to take us to the city center for some shopping. Luckily, the rickshaw driver turned out to be a Muslim, and coming to know that we were visitors from Pakistan, was so thrilled that he insisted that he would take us everywhere on his vehicle whenever we wanted. He would come every day and park his rickshaw outside our hotel in the morning regardless of when Tabana would be ready to move out.
I went to the office on Monday and joined the conference which was being chaired by MD India, Joe Remedios. It was 20th August 2000. Later in the morning his secretary of came to see me saying that she had received an urgent call from our Karachi office asking me to ring back. I immediately called my secretary Gulshan who told me that Mansoor Bhai had called her to give me the news that Tabana’s elder brother Zamir Bhai, living in Virginia in the United States, had passed away earlier that day. He was a career World Bank employee but was now retired and was busy in his garden when he suffered a massive heart attack. He died almost immediately. I was stunned, took leave from Remedios and rushed back to the hotel. I have no recollection of how I broke the news to Tabana and what happened during the rest of the day. We wanted to get back to Pakistan but it was not possible due to the very limited number of flights between the two countries. The thrill was now gone and the rest of our stay in Bangalore was spent like a formality. Tabana had a worse time missing her near and dear ones to share her grief. We left Bangalore for Mumbai on the morning of 23 August.
Reaching Mumbai, we found a room in a hotel booked for us which was situated in the Juhu area. Thickly populated kholi’s lined the road all the way from the airport to the hotel on both sides. It was a medium class hotel but quite comfortable. I was resting in our room after lunch when a telephone call woke me up. It was the receptionist who told me that there was a man from the Indian intelligence agency who wanted to see me urgently. I got very worried, rushed downstairs with the passports and found a man dressed in a trouser and open shirt waiting for me at the reception desk. He demanded to know why I had not registered with the police immediately after arrival which was the requirement for all visitors from Pakistan. I told him politely that our passports had expressly exempted us from this requirement. He did not believe me and demanded to see the passports. Finding the exemption there he became visibly upset and after asking a few more questions demanded that I provide him with photocopies of our passports. I had no idea how I could manage this but the receptionist came to my rescue and offered to arrange the photocopies. The Intelligence man left in a surly mood and it was obvious that he felt disappointed missing an opportunity offering a lot of potential.
In the evening, we hired a taxi and told the taxi driver to show us around. The taxi driver who was named Ganesh started talking to us in Hindi/Urdu and coming to know that we were visiting from Pakistan immediately shot a question, “Are you from Kargil?” The question amazed us and I explained to him that we had not come from Kargil but from Karachi. His next question was even more baffling, “Have you been to Kargil?” I again explained to him that Kargil was a long way away from Karachi and there was no reason for us to go there, ever. Having concluded this interview apparently to his satisfaction, he opened up to us. He started a lively conversation and showed us many interesting places in the city including the residences of some famous movie stars like Amitabh Buchan and Madhuri Dixit. We also went to the Juhu beach but it was quite crowded and we could not get near the water.
I realized for the first time what a deep impact the Kargil war had made on the Indian psyche. The war had been fought between India and Pakistan from May to July 1999 in the Ladakh area of Kashmir along the line of control. This was the first war between the two nations when the Indian mass media played a significant part in influencing public opinion. News stories and war footage was telecast live on Indian TV fostering belligerent feelings in the minds of the public. Arrival of hundreds of body bags in the plains of India as the war progressed turned these feelings into anger against Pakistan especially as the war had produced higher than expected fatalities for the Indian military, with a sizeable percentage of them being newly commissioned officers. On the other hand, Kargil war had made little impact in the minds of Pakistani public except highlighting political differences between the prime minister and the army chief. These tensions eventually resulted in the dismissal of the civilian government and military coming to power in October 1999.
Reaching the airport next morning four hours before flight time as advised by the travel agent, we found a long queue waiting to enter the ticket hall. Each piece of the travelers’ luggage was being loaded on the security conveyer belt one at a time, X-rayed and then a paper seal manually pasted on the lock. The belt was obviously moving at a snail’s pace. The baggage was also being recorded in thick registers in long hand by a couple of assistants. Reaching the immigration counter, our passports were checked very carefully but in a civil manner, very much unlike the reception we had encountered on arrival.
Having parked ourselves in the departure lounge, we had some snacks and, after the flight was called, started moving towards the departure gate. Hardly had we reached the gate however, when we heard a call on the speaker asking us to report back to somebody in the departure lounge. Hearts thumping, we rushed back. Fortunately, the call had been made only to clarify some point regarding my passport and we were allowed to proceed again after a few minutes.
We moved slowly towards the plane joining other people. Boarding cards were checked near the gate and we were finally inside the plane. It might be our imagination but it appeared to both of us that we had suddenly entered another world: a cheerful, familiar and pleasant world. Without thinking, we instantly uttered the words, “Thank God.” I have never felt so happy in my life entering a PIA plane as I did on that occasion.
----------
(5)
A few weeks after coming back from India, I was sitting with our distributor Ijaz Shaikh in his Lahore office when he casually mentioned that he had performed Hajj earlier that year and found it to be a highly pleasant and mentally reinvigorating experience. He then encouraged me to do the same. I did not give it much thought at the time but after coming back to Karachi, could not shake this thought out of my mind. I discussed this with Mansoor Bhai who seemed quite enthusiastic to the idea and told me to explore this further. Having checked around, I found many tour operators specializing in organizing group Hajj and Umrah but one name stood out, Pakistan Pilgrims Society, a non-profit organization with an excellent reputation in this field. Unlike other groups, the Society had a fixed number of one hundred pilgrims for performing Hajj every year. I wasn’t too sure if I would be allowed extended leave from my office but having explained its purpose to my British boss Jonathan Lea, he readily agreed. At this stage, Mansoor Bhai opted out of the program due to some personal reasons. I too started wavering but then I received a call from my young cousin Zoobi who was living in Saudi Arabia and had performed Hajj multiple times before. He told me forcefully that now that I had done all the preliminaries, I must not step back, this won’t be right; this helped me to firm up my resolve and, Tabana being equally willing, we decided to go ahead. I visited the Society’s office to book our passage to the holy land; Rs 90,000 per person covering the total Hajj expenditure for a full forty days package including eight days in Madinah. We were now all set to go.
Preparations had to be made before we actually boarded the plane. There were introductory classes held every Sunday arranged by the Society for explaining the religious and procedural requirements for Hajj. A lot of shopping was to be done and we found that there was an entire market near Boulton Market exclusively selling Hajj paraphernalia, everything imaginable under the sun one might require in Makkah or Madinah during the stay there. There was a Hajj camp arranged by the government providing facilities for vaccination and for getting the list of personal medications certified by a doctor. The Hajj was already proving to be a grand social event allowing people from all walks of life to get together selflessly for a common cause, indeed the very essence of Hajj.
Finally, the day came when we were to depart. I put on the ihram, the unstitched white garment, in preparation for performing Umrah and we reached the airport four hours before flight time as required. The flight departed on time and reaching Jeddah in the afternoon, we boarded the buses arranged by Society for transporting us to Makkah. Every few minutes we would recite the Talbiyah, a prayer one is required to recite frequently during Hajj days. It was close to midnight by the time we got to our destination, a hostel situated on the road to Mina about twenty minutes’ walk from Haram. My home for the duration of Hajj was now a mid-sized room containing six mattresses spread out on the floor where I would spend, along with my five roommates who soon became friends, almost the whole of my time there. Tabana had been allotted a similar room in the women’s wing. I had placed next to my mattress my hand carry bag containing everything that I could bring for this trip: clothes, toiletries, travel documents, books, travelers’ cheques - in short, my world. Most of my time would now be spent rummaging through my bag every few hours trying frantically to find one thing or other.
The next morning, we performed Umrah in a group. We were guided to enter the Haram through the Bab-us-Salam gate, one of the twelve gates there. Reaching there made me understand, why. It is the only gate where you can get to look at the Holy Kaaba as you enter Haram from a far distance. And what a sight it is for a first-time visitor. I turned a corner and there it was, in its full glory and splendor. I had seen its pictures innumerable times before but nothing had prepared me for its grandeur and its majesty. I could not control my emotions which overwhelmed me; tears started rolling down my eyes and I stood transfixed there. It is said that a first-time prayer there is always answered. I prayed; words were tumbling through my mind but I didn’t care.
We moved inside the Haram, performed Tawaf, the ritual of walking seven times around Kaaba, and reassembled at the pre-arranged meeting point of the ‘Green Light’ shining in a corner of the Haram. It wasn’t very crowded there as it was early days yet but I was still surprised by the elbowing and jostling by some overzealous pilgrims. From there, we proceeded to perform the Sa’i, the ritual of walking seven times between the hills of Safa and Marwa to remember Bibi Hajirah’s frantic search for water for her little son Ismael.
Life then took on a set routine. We would go to the Haram multiple times during the day or night to offer our prayers, spend some time there and then return to the hostel, that is, to the beloved mattress. Many times during the day, I would go and standing outside the women’s quarters ask somebody to fetch Tabana, or more likely call Tabana in a loud voice which would cause some hilarity in those quarters. For meals, we would go down to one of the many Pakistani restaurants situated nearby which offered passable food. Most of my time in the room was spent talking to the room mates, reading books, or just sleeping because there was no concept of night or day there. In fact, praying in the Haram during night time could be a very pleasant experience. The Society had arranged for occasional bus rides to the many historical sites having religious significance dotted around the city. We would have plenty of fruits or other snacks to enjoy on the way and the trips looked more like a picnic than a religious outing.
Our Group leader was Ghulam Abbas Badami, a delightful personality. A veteran of many Hajj trips, he guided us expertly though the requirements and rituals of Hajj. At one of our introductory classes in Karachi, he made an announcement appointing me as the Chairman Finance Committee which surprised me as much as it did others. All members of the Group had been asked to contribute Riyals 150 each to a special fund which was used to buy refreshments for the road trips or other such expenses. The job of the Finance Committee was to keep a record of this fund.
Soon after reaching Makkah, I found that the Finance Committee comprised a single member, me. This was a highly onerous job but I welcomed it considering it as part of my Hajj duty. Group members started to visit to deposit their contributions and I maintained a diary to record these payments. Every evening I would tally the cash in hand with the balance in the diary. Things were going well but three or four days later, all members having paid their contribution, I found that I was six hundred Riyals short – equal to the contribution of four members. I went through my records again, checked and rechecked the cash, but the shortage remained. I told the Group Leader about this who consoled me saying not to worry, such things happened. But I was devastated blaming myself for this negligence. It wasn’t a question of money; it was my credibility. I went to the Haram that night and prayed fervently asking Allah to get me out of this trouble.
Early the next morning at about half past eight, I was told that some people were waiting outside the room to see me. I went out, met two people I had never seen before, who told me that they had just been to the bank which opened at 08.00 and wanted to pay their contribution. They apologized for the delay in payment saying that the previous day being a Friday, they could not withdraw money from the bank. Coming back, I checked my records and, sure enough, I had considered them as having made the payment though their names were still unticked. Discovering this error, I rechecked my diary and found two other names similarly unticked where payment was still due. My cash shortage of six hundred Riyals stood reconciled.
While all this could have been a coincidence, why did these two people feel the need to rush almost at the crack of dawn to see me, remains unexplained. Mysterious are the ways of the Creator.
Eight days before the Hajj we boarded buses for Madinah. Reaching there about four hours later, we found that the rooms booked by Society for us, though about the same size as the ones in Makkah, had eight mattresses in each room cramped together. Using the bathroom was going to be a challenge because of the two bathrooms available for men in our section, one was out of order. Having gone through that experience, I relish the luxury of my bathroom at home which I can use whenever I want to instead of queuing for one endlessly.
As I was setting up my things on the mattress allotted to me, a man with a thick bushy bearded came barging in and claimed that this was ‘his’ mattress. I told him that I was there as advised by the management, but he started shouting. There was no option but to move to another room. Later that evening, there was another commotion when the man came barging into my room again, forcibly hugged me and started crying. He was begging my forgiveness. I did not understand at first what it was all about until he explained that he had committed a grave error evicting me from my room earlier, wanted me to go back to that room, and to forgive him. I told him that I was fine where I was and that there was nothing to forgive for, but he kept on insisting that I forgive him and left only after I did so. People told me that having done the deed, he must have been hit by his conscience telling him that this was Hajj and he must not do anything to jeopardize it. One only wishes that people display the same conscientiousness in their normal life that they do during the time of Hajj.
The next morning, our Group marched towards the Masjid e Nabawi, the sacred place which is close to every Muslim’s heart. It was truly impressive with vast marble halls shaded by huge canopies. It had been my ardent wish to pray inside the Riyaz ul Jannah (literally meaning Garden of Paradise), a historically and spiritually revered area inside the Masjid, but it was too crowed that day. The next day, I went there early and standing next to the partition separating it from the main hall, inched forward until the time when entry was opened and managed to get in. Once there, I thought I must make full use of this opportunity and stayed there for well over an hour praying. Coming back to the hostel I shared my experience with some other people including our Maulana Sahib.
Like all pilgrim groups, we had a religious scholar accompanying us for the pilgrimage, Maulana Muhammad Ali Naqvi. He was a young man in his early thirties, who doubled as our guide explaining historic and religious significance of the sites in and around Makkah and Madinah. He was light-hearted and good-natured, always had a smile on his face and was very popular among the ladies and the young crowd in our Group. The women used to pepper him with questions about the religious rites and rituals but he always answered them patiently. I once said to him that had he charged a Riyal for each question answered by him, he would have been a millionaire by now. With his usual humor he replied, “You should have told me before.”
We had a session in the hostel every evening attended by Group members where the management reviewed the day’s events and outlined the program for the next day. Maulana Sb would also make a short address commenting on the religious aspects of the program. This was all very well but sometimes the address turned into a sharp rebuke or even condemnation of something happening during the day if this did not meet with his approval. On our very first day in Haram, after completing the Tawaf, we were sitting together taking a breather under the Green Light when somebody happened to make a comment that he had completed the Tawaf in record time and was back before everybody else. Little did he know what awaited him in the evening. Maulana Sb after a few general comments raised his voice and thundered, “Some people (this was his favorite expression), in their zeal to complete the Tawaf in as little time as possible, jostle and push and elbow other pilgrims. They don’t care that there are women around them, there are elderly people and there are people weaker than them. All they care about is their speed.” He went on in the same vein for a few more minutes and all this time, he never looked at the person concerned, he did not even glance in that direction. But the person knew well.
I received a similar treatment after my afternoon in Riyaz ul Jannah and it came totally unexpected. Having delt with the day’s program, he started in a gentle voice gradually increasing in tempo. “Some people,” he announced, “go to Riyaz ul Jannah to pray with the other pilgrims. This is commendable. But once they are there, they make themselves a permanent fixture there. They go on offering prayer after prayer, happy that Allah would love them for it. Little do they know that there many other people yearning to do the same, people who have come from far away hoping to get a glimpse of this Holy place but cannot get inside because it is already full. These people don’t care; they want the maximum blessings for themselves.” He went on like this for some time and, while he hardly ever looked in my direction, I knew perfectly well what he meant and was shrinking within myself with embarrassment.
I had been suffering from Eczema for about a year, a skin disease causing itching and rashes, which was kept in control with regular application of creams and ointments. The only visible sign of it so far was redness of skin. In Saudi Arabia, the redness gradually started to turn into tiny blisters. Madinah has a very dry climate, so dry in fact that Vaseline, a well-known cream used for dry skin, was sold not just in pharmacies, but in small bottles loaded in hundreds on pushcarts, like apples or oranges. My blisters started to swell and expand in Madinah. They were concentrated mostly on the back, shoulders and the arms
Eight days here were quickly over and we were now ready for performing Hajj. We proceeded to Masjid Bir Ali, located about eleven kilometers from Masjid e Nabawi to put on ihram. Stopping over for a short time in Makkah, the buses took us to Mina and onwards to our destination Mount Arafat. We spent the night there sleeping on thin carpets spread out under the tents. The next day was 9 Zul-Hajj, the day of the Arafah, the pinnacle of Hajj pilgrimage. Whole of this day was devoted to offering prayers and listening to holy sermons. Many Pakistani pilgrims who were living in Saudi Arabia and had come to perform Hajj joined our Group there. Among these was my cousin Zoobi and also, by the strangest of coincidences, another cousin Nihal Azhar who I hadn’t seen in years. Nihal was a doctor by profession, born and educated in Islamabad. He was a kind of vagabond by nature, wandering about the world and healing his patients in far off places, in countries like Malaysia, Libya and Yemen. But for me seeing him in Arafat, my heart leapt with joy. He was nothing but a gift sent for me by God. My blisters had by now swelled further and then ruptured leaving behind open skin wounds which started to bleed. Nihal took one look at them and immediately got to work. He washed the wounds gently with soap and water and then put bandages upon them. Almost half of my body was covered with bandages by then. I was feeling a lot more comfortable after the treatment, especially now that the bleeding had stopped.
After sunset, it was time to proceed to Muzdalifah by bus, pick up pebbles for throwing stones at the four pillars in Mina (called Rami) and spend the night under the open sky. Women and senior citizens in the meantime had gone directly from Arafat to Mina. In the morning after offering Fajr prayers, we started the long march towards our reserved tents in Mina and completed the ritual of throwing pebbles at the largest pillar.
The next step for us was to offer Qurbani, the animal sacrifice to commemorate Prophet Ibrahim offering his son Ismael for sacrifice. Most of the pilgrims opt to deposit a fixed sum in a bank account earmarked by the Saudi Government for this purpose but the Society had arranged for us to go to an officially designated slaughterhouse to perform qurbani. We proceeded by bus to that location and found a highly organized and well managed system for pilgrims there. The Group members made pairs of two people each to perform qurbani together and I joined my roommate Jafar for this purpose. The two of us had been given responsibility of sacrificing six animals each; I was doing it for myself, for Tabana and for my two other roommates, both senior citizens, as well as for the wife of one and daughter of the other.
Going in, we found a strange sight: dozens of sheep were wallowing and rolling in a sea of thick mud in a big hall. We were supposed to go there and to bring them physically to an adjoining hall where these were to be sacrificed. The entire floor of the second hall was made of metal grille to instantly drain the massive amount of animal blood accumulating there. Getting the sheep to move from the first to the second hall was easier said than done; the sheep stubbornly refused to move an inch while the muddy ground was extremely slippery. We first tried to drag them gently holding them by their head, but having failed, found another practical way. We took hold of their feet and then dragged them backwards, much like you would hold a wheelbarrow walking back. The sheep, finding their two feet locked in our hands, had little choice but to walk back meekly and submit to their fate.
We were still in Ihram but were by now covered in thick mud from head to foot. I suddenly realized that all this was part of Hajj, in fact one of its most important parts, and was proving to be the most arduous one as well. One by one, we managed to bring all the twelve sheep to the second hall and, having completed the job, phoned Tabana to convey this message to all concerned. After coming back, we had our heads shaved and could now have a bath and change into normal clothes.
Two more days were spent in Mina for rami on each day and then it was time for us to return. It suddenly started raining heavily at the time we were boarding the bus and by the time I got in, I was thoroughly drenched. It was freezing in the bus due to heavy air conditioning and by the time we reached our hostel in Makkah, I had caught a cough. This was to remain with me like an uninvited guest for the rest of my stay. The next morning, I went down to the restaurant to have tea and the owner, who knew me well by now, announced that the cough was a sign that my Hajj had been accepted! He had found a good way to make his customers happy.
The blisters were proving to be a nuisance. I had to be extremely careful during Tawaf because even a small touch would run the risk of starting the bleeding. After a couple of days, I took a taxi and went to a government hospital located a few miles away from the city. It was a far cry from hospitals in Pakistan; extremely neat and clean, nurses in smart white uniforms moving about giving patients immediate attention. They looked at my blisters, cleaned and bandaged them but at the same time advised me to go back to Pakistan as soon as possible because the dry weather here was not good for skin allergies. There were still more than two weeks to go before our scheduled departure and the only way the date could be advanced was to get it changed by the Ministry officials at Pakistan House. The next morning, I collected the documents and landed there, patiently sitting on the ground in a queue with all other supplicants in the lounge. The official concerned arrived after an hour or so, a young man probably a deputy secretary, well-mannered and polite. He asked me why I wanted to advance the date of my departure, I showed him the medical records and without saying another word, took off my shirt. He was duly impressed and immediately booked seats for us on a flight leaving three days later.
Luckily, Mr. Haider Wadia - the Society representative in Jeddah - was visiting Makkah and it was arranged that we could accompany him in his car on his return journey. I had to close the Group cash fund in my custody. There was a surplus in this account and I put up a notice on the notice board asking all members to collect their share of the surplus from me by the next day. It was time now to say good bye to all my dear roommates I had spent days and nights with, Badami Sb, Maulana Sb and many other people I had become very close to during our long stay in Makkah. Tabana did the same and we finally left the hostel in Wadia Sb’s car around midnight. He had his friend sitting next to him while I and Tabana were in the back. I was feeling extremely tired and immediately went to sleep. I am not sure how long I had slept when the sound of a car radio slowly penetrated my consciousness and I woke up, it was BBC Radio and two people were talking in English. It is difficult to forget that moment; the sound hit me like a flash of lightening, it was like I had woken up after a long dream and emerged into a different world. For the past thirty days, I had not seen TV or listened to radio nor read any newspaper, and had used my phone only a couple of times briefly to confirm my welfare. My world was confined to Haram and a room with six mattresses. When I got bored, I would sit on the stairs of the hostel building and watch traffic going about on the road. I was now suddenly being made aware of another world awaiting me out there and the idea did not seem very appealing to me.
Landing in Karachi, we were welcomed by family members holding garlands in their hands, few of whom were able to recognize me in my long white beard. We went home to even a bigger welcome though I would often fall asleep in the middle of a conversation due to extreme tiredness and fatigue. Life began to return to normal though strangely, for both of us, our hearts were still in Makkah; we were finding it difficult to adjust to the new life. TV came to our rescue. We tuned in to the Saudi channel broadcasting live transmission of Haram twenty-four hours a day, and would sit in front of TV watching people doing Tawaf and moving about there. Somehow it brough Makkah into our home, the place we wanted to be more than anywhere else.
The worldly responsibilities took control of our lives again. I experienced one of the happiest days of my life when my daughter Alina was born in July 2002 and I became a proud father. I began to experience the joys (and the sleepless nights) of parenthood. Alina’s birth created great elation and excitement in our family. As the news spread, people started to arrive in our home and after a while it seemed that there were guests occupying almost every room in the house. The merriment continued till late in the night. There was another addition in our family when my son Adil joined us two years later. Thanks to Tabana’s care for the children day and night, they have developed into young adults and the joys of our life.
-----------
(6)
One of the fringe benefits of going for Hajj was that I was now the proud owner of a mobile phone (or cell phone as it is called in the US), my first ever. This was a recent development and few people owned a mobile phone or even knew about it in those days. It was a Nokia brand from Finland, the most popular brand in those days, so much that Nokia had almost become the generic name for mobile phones. It had a tiny keyboard and an even smaller screen only showing dialed or received phone numbers and menu. Sadly, its reign came to end with the development of smart phones and the launch of Apple iPhone in 2007 combing the phone with iPod and internet communicator. The iPhone revolutionized mobile phone technology with substitution of physical keyboards with multi-touch screen.
I have always hated telephones. In my view, they are a terrible infringement of privacy; forcing you to talk when you don’t want to talk, which for me is often. Among all the gifts of science to mankind, I think telephones must be the worst. As if the landline wasn’t enough, invention of mobile phones made the situation infinitely worse; with landline phones, you could least be free of them if you were away from home or office, with mobile phones one was on call twenty-four hours a day. I had resisted getting one as long as I could. Not that I could have; until very recently they were so bulky and heavy that carrying a mobile was like holding a transistor radio or cassette player in your hand. One could, if one wanted, buy a satellite phone which were a reasonable size but they were quite expensive and also, what was the use if nobody else had them. Getting a mobile phone before leaving for Hajj however made sense due to the need to remain in constant touch with people back home. I was loathe to use it and hardly ever picked it up except for answering calls from home.
A more popular means of communication in those days was emails, introduced only a few years back. I had writing emails when there would not have been more than a thousand email subscribers in Pakistan, facilitated by a local internet service provider called Digi Com. Other than company correspondence, there were not many people I could get in touch with on email in those days, and I remember sending messages to my sister Nageen in US only through emails sent to an American intermediary.
Connecting to the internet in those days was possible only through telephone line and it was a long and slow process. The computer had to make a phone call using a device called a dial-up modem. First, we heard the dial tone and then the sound of touch-tone beeps dialing the internet service provider. There were one or two telephone rings followed by a loud static. It began with sharp, high-pitched squeals, changed to a mechanical, rhythmic wheezing, and ended with a rushing "shhhhh" sound of white noise. The line then suddenly went dead silent. The silence was a good thing because it meant that the computer was finally connected to the World Wide Web.
We had to remain cool and patient, as speeds were incredibly slow, usually 28.8k to 56k bits per second. WWW used to be called World Waiting Web. Text websites loaded line by line. An image would slowly emerge from top to bottom over several minutes, resembling a window shade being pulled down. Downloading a short video clip could take hours, and a single dropped connection meant having to start the process all over again.
The modem took control of the phone line and internet use by a single user affected the entire family. Anyone calling your phone while you were online received a busy signal. Family members would shout at you to "get off the computer NOW" because they needed to make a phone call.
----------
(7)
Coats regional office had scheduled a meeting in Istanbul on 30 September 1997 and I left to attend it a day earlier coming back on 2 October. My secretary Gulshan quipped that I had gone as a finance director and came back as managing director. There was a big difference in the size of my room; I had gotten used to the tiny room I had been occupying for the past five years and felt too small sitting here. But the more pressing concern was the realization that I had practically nothing to do! Except for attending meetings, which meant talk, talk, talk, there was not much to do: no accounts to prepare, no loans to negotiate and no payments to approve. What does a chief executive do all day? Life was going to be tough sitting doing nothing. I started by developing a plan of things to be done in the next three months: things like putting in new machinery, responding to customer feedback and complaints, new product development, sales conference and, most important, departments’ restructuring. One of the most important and urgent tasks was to obtain ISO 9000 certification which would mean setting up systems to consistently maintain superior quality of company’s products.
Syed Babar Ali, the famous business leader and philanthropist of the country, visited the company a few weeks later. He had a brief chat with me and offered many valuable pieces of advice like, as he put it, “getting rid of the dead wood”. J&P Coats had started operations in Pakistan in 1948, almost immediately after partition, and the credit for bringing the investment to Pakistan belonged to his family. Ali Group was a minority shareholder in the company holding 40% shares and was represented on the board of directors by a family member, Syed Kamal Ali. They were an ideal minority partner, never interfering in the company’s affairs but always available for consultation and support. In fact, many foreign companies who were looking to set up joint ventures in those early days partnered with Syed Babar Ali due to his sterling credentials.
Syed Babar Ali had established Packages Limited back in 1956 as a joint venture with Rausing, the Swedish family firm. This partnership later set up Tetra Pak and Milk Pak, now Nestle Pakistan Ltd, which is one of the largest food processing companies in Pakistan. Later other companies were set up but these suffered a major setback in early seventies during Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto’s nationalization drive, devouring five companies belonging to the group: Ali Automobiles, Wazir Ali Engineering, Wazir Ali Industries, Treet Corporation and the life insurance business of International General Insurance Company. Still, considering it as a public duty, he agreed to become chairman of the government owned National Fertiliser Corporation.
Syed Babar Ali briefly served as finance minister in 1993 under caretaker prime minister Moeen Qureshi after the fall of Nawaz Sharif government. The interim government devaluated Pakistani currency, increased prices of daily use commodities, targeted tax evaders and loan defaulters, and tried to broaden the tax base. Orders were issued to give complete autonomy to the State Bank of Pakistan. It also published for the first time a tax payers’ directory despite strong opposition from powerful lobbies.
Syed Babar Ali’s crowning achievement remains the Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) fulfilling his vision “to create a class of people that would be an asset to the nation, not just graduates.” He personally collected funds for the University from whatever source he could, government, business leaders, companies. He convinced Dean Hinton, the American ambassador to Pakistan, to divert a part of US financial assistance for Pakistan to LUMS. Agreeing to match donations received from US with an equal local contribution, SBA negotiated $10 million (about $40 million today) with Hinton.
I used to meet Babar Ali Sb occasionally when I visited Lahore and he was available. I would sometimes be invited by him for lunch in the Packages Ltd dining room where he took his lunch sitting with other employees of the company without any formality. I was always deeply impressed with the modesty and humility of this great man. Babar Ali Sb would help me greatly a few years later with a company project which would not have been possible without his intervention.
Meric Ulgen did not stay long as the regional head ending my reporting relationship with him, which had worked very well and which I had greatly valued and enjoyed. After a global business reorganization in April 1999, he was promoted as head of Global Operations and Europe. Pakistan being a geo-political anomaly in the Coats hierarchy, not being part of Asia-Pacific nor Middle-East, I ended up reporting to the Group Finance Director Jonathan Lea as my regional head. This was not ideal because Jonathan hardly ever found time for us and this meant having to visit England almost every quarter. Another reorganization in summer 2001 found me reporting to Joe Remedios, MD India, who was now head of the newly created region of South Asia.
Remedios was an odd character. An Anglo-Indian, he was the son of an Indian railway engine driver, with the build, crudity and temperament of a steam engine. From the very beginning I was skeptical of this arrangement due to the near-impossibility of travel between the two countries but the colonial outlook of our British masters brushed aside these ground realities. Around the time of this change over, I was lobbying the head office to obtain approval for setting up a Coats factory in Lahore. There were many reasons for this: demand for industrial threads was increasing at a fast pace and most of it was coming from the Lahore region. Large apparel, home textiles and jeans manufacturing units were coming up there as Punjab always had a thriving textile industry. It made sense to expand our operations close to our emerging customer base. We prepared a decent investment proposal showing good returns and sent it to Remedios for submission to the Board. After the meeting, Remedios sent me an email declaring almost gleefully, “Saeed, your proposal has gone for a six.” Undeterred, we prepared an even better-looking proposal next year and back came the stock reply from Remedios after the meeting, “Your proposal has gone for a six again, Saeed”, showing not only his lack of vision but also lack of vocabulary. All this time we were never told how the discussion went in the board meeting nor the grounds for its rejection.
I was now convinced that this route would never get me the results we were looking for. Knowing Babar Ali Sb, I decided to seek his help and took an appointment to see him in Lahore. He listened to me, got to the root of the matter immediately, and told me not to worry, he will get the job done. On his next visit to England, he sought a meeting with our group chief executive Martin Flower. After coming back he gave me the good news that our project had been approved and we should soon receive the official notification.
Pakistan was not an unfamiliar territory for Martin Flower. A tall and handsome Englishman with an upper-class upbringing, he used to be head of Coats Asia-Pacific region when Pakistan was part of this region. Very fond of cricket, he was a member of Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC) with its headquarters at the Lord’s cricket ground and proud of it. Once while we were in London, he took us for a visit to the cricket museum there containing priceless photographs of great cricketing events. We saw the famous stuffed bird which was killed in mid-air in 1936 while flying at Lord’s cricket ground, struck by a ball during bowling by Indian fast bowler Jahangir Khan.
Martin Flower once visited Pakistan in the mid-nineties and we arranged for him to go to Lahore to see its historical sites and meet Syed Babar Ali. It was a party of four including Meric Ulgen, Anisur Rahman and myself. After spending the day there, we were to return by the evening flight, reaching Karachi in time for a dinner with the senior Coats managers at a club. We were cruising somewhere near Bahawalpur when there was suddenly an announcement by the captain telling us that we were unable to land at Karachi airport due to some technical reasons and the flight was being diverted back to Lahore. Our carefully laid out plans were thrown out of the window. Landing in Lahore, we were having drinks in the lounge when a member of the PIA staff confided to us the reason for flight’s diversion. Airport Control Karachi had received a message from the staff of Mr. Asif Ali Zardari, husband of prime minister Benazir Bhutto and given the same protocol as the prime minister, that a plane carrying him from Quetta was about to land at Karachi and all flights arriving there were to be diverted until Mr. Zardari had been safely driven out of the airport. I was watching Martin Flower; he turned red in the face and controlled his temper with some difficulty. He had probably never seen anything remotely like this all his life.
Work started immediately on finding a suitable greenfield site for the project and one was found soon, a six-acre plot on Raiwind Road about half an hour drive from Lahore city center situated almost next to the Coca-Cola factory. Plans were developed by Coats technical team and buildings erected using prefabricated roofing systems. Machinery procurement and installation as well as staff recruitment and training were supervised by the expert staff of Coats technical teams to meet its global standards, and we were in business much earlier than expected. The successful and thriving J&P Coats Lahore manufacturing plant serving customers in this region owes its origin to Syed Babar Ali.
--------
(8)
Like its Anchor brand embroidery threads, JP Coats was also famous for producing high quality kite flying threads. A considerable portion of our sales originated from this source, and a very profitable one. Basant, the annual kite flying festival, was celebrated in cities all over Pakistan providing a source of fun and enjoyment to the young people, and we used to receive many requests from kite flying connoisseurs for reels of this thread to avoid buying counterfeit Coats products in the market.
Basant is a seasonal Punjabi festival celebrating spring and historically associated with yellow attire and kite flying. It is said to have Sufi origin dating back to the 13th century started by poet Amir Khosrow to lift the spirits of his murshid Nizamuddin Auliya, using yellow sunflowers and music. It soon spread to Punjab and in the nineteenth century, Maharaja Ranjeet Singh held grand Basant durbars in Lahore where troops and nobles wore yellow clothes, He introduced kite flying as a regular feature associated with annual Basant fair.
Until about 2005, Basant used to be celebrated by the people of Lahore with great zeal and fervor, marked by vibrant kite flying, rooftop gatherings, music and all-night parties. Tourists came from all over the world to participate in these festivities and for weeks there was a carnival like atmosphere in the city. Young people were especially attracted to kite flying and waited the whole year saving money to spend during Basant days. All this came to a sudden halt when a ban on kite flying was imposed by the Punjab government in 2005 after a series of deaths and serious injuries caused by the lethal kite flying thread.
It all started when the size of kites began to grow bigger and bigger. The normal kite flying thread, made from cotton, could not support the weight of these kites and began to be replaced by first by heavily glass-coated, and then by Nylon and metal strings. These strings proved to be deadly, leading to tragic throat-cutting incidents, not only for kids flying kites but innocent strangers. Metal thread also caused electrocution from contact with overhead power cables.
The government failed to control the manufacture and sale of lethal thread for many years despite being fully aware of its harmful effects, nor did it take any steps to ban the sale of large kites. The kite flying ban was also favored by, or as some people said engineered by, an influential group of religiously minded persons who were opposed to Basant because of its alleged Hindu origins. This included some very powerful political leaders from Lahore.
Into this fray entered the Supreme Court of Pakistan headed by Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry in 2005. The court took a suo motu action and imposed a ban on kite flying and sale of kite and dangerous strings issuing detailed instructions to the provincial government. The court continued its hearings until 2007 when it refused to grant its approval for relaxation of the ban unless the provincial and local governments took decisive measures to regulate the industry and guarantee people’s safety. This effectively led to continuation of the ban till very recently. According to a conservative estimate, more than one hundred thousand people associated with kite flying industry and its ancillary trades lost their jobs as a result of this ban in addition to the loss of millions of rupees in economic value and taxes.
A look at the kite flying scenario in India might not be out of place here. Kite flying industry in the state of Gujarat, which is India’s largest kite manufacturing center and about 65% of the national market, is presently valued at about 70 million US dollars annually. India also suffers from serious injuries and deaths attributable to kite flying but the number of these incidents in Gujarat is miniscule compared to those in Punjab. And there is a good reason for this. In India there is greater emphasis on regulation than on prohibition. There is a total ban on dangerous threads of all kinds which is enforced very strictly. Kite flying has been preserved as a cultural festival and sport, providing jobs to millions of people and giving a major boost to the local economy.
---------
(9)
The official retirement age in the Coats Group was fifty-eight years. I was reminded of my age when I received an email from Remedios, his usual mode of communication with me, that I shall retire in April 2006 but shall continue in office until a suitable replacement was found. I had completed almost nine years in this job and was not too anxious to continue further, spending rest of my life receiving emails from him. Happily, after searching around for almost six months around the globe, no better candidate could be found to succeed me as the company’s chief executive than our own finance director, Amyn Currimbhoy, who had been with us for as long as I had been MD. He was eminently suitable for this job, both in ability and in temperament, and was to remain as the company’s CEO for a long time. He took over from me on 30th September and it was nine years to the day since I had joined this office in 1997. I had spent a total of fifteen very happy and enjoyable years with Coats.
My farewell from Coats was a grand affair taking the form of an open-air public meeting held at the factory because the workers and staff also wanted to participate in the event. I was not aware of the kind of feelings the employees had in their hearts for me and was overwhelmed by their warmth and affection.
I had said goodbye to Coats with the firm resolve to enjoy my retirement fully for the rest of my days in life. I had waited for this day for a very long time, practically counting the days to my retirement. I had always hated going to the office every morning, having to rush through reading my newspaper, finishing a quick breakfast and then a hurried drive to the office. I longed for a day when I would have enough time in the morning to read the newspaper cover to cover, following it up with a relaxed breakfast, after I which I would sit in the lawn all day reading my favorite book and listening to music, dozing off whenever I wanted to. No worry in the world.
I had started going to an office daily and working morning till evening since the age of nineteen. This was when I had started post B. Com internship at Fergusons followed by grant of articles there, and this routine had continued for the next forty years. Dreaming of retirement I had two major fears. The first was a world war; I dreaded that if an atomic warfare started before my retirement annihilating everything, I might be left out in the cold before enjoying a day of my post-retirement bliss, and this would be a disaster. An even greater fear was that the day of judgement might arrive before my retirement with the same results. Though like all good Muslims I too waited for the day of judgement with eager anticipation, I just wanted it to happen a few years after my retirement so that I could at least enjoy some of its fruits.
The days immediately after my retirement were indeed a bliss. I went to bed every night happy that I won’t have to go to the office the next morning. I spent a lot of time with the newspaper; spent a leisurely day reading books and listening to my favorite music. There were many unfinished house maintenance jobs that needed giving attention to. A month went by, then another month, and the bliss slowly started to lose its shine. By the end of the third month, I was feeling restless. By the end of the fourth, I had started serious job hunting. I then realized something I hadn’t before: retiring before sixty appeared to some people to be too soon, but in fact it was excellent timing. It was easier to find a new job at this age than, say, when one was in the mid or late sixties when it would become much harder.
I applied and after a series of interviews was offered the job of chief executive of a company mining and marketing gems and jewellery. The company had just been formed as a non-profit public/private entity and the job was extremely exciting and challenging. I was about to confirm my acceptance when I received an unexpected call from Anisur Rahman, my ex-boss at JP Coats, who was now working for a Swiss Company called SICPA, producing security inks for the printing of currency notes and other government documents. His finance director had suddenly resigned and, not only was he leaving the job, he had given the company only a week to find a replacement. And a quick replacement had become all the more urgent because the company’s annual general meeting was due to be held in Switzerland after only three weeks and the meeting could not be held without the finance director. I went to see Anis Sb the next day when he offered me the job containing terms one could not lightly brush aside like it being a regular (and not a contractual) job with full retirement benefits and, as usual, appointment of a secretary for me. There were only two directors in the company, the other one being the operations director Tanviruddin Ahmed, responsible for manufacturing and sales.
I was now in a fix. I consulted my old friend Abdullah who was currently Chairman, Federal Board of Revenue because few people knew public sector companies like he did and also because he had helped me during the selection process for the gems company. His view was very clear; I had spent my life working at multi-national companies and would be much happier remaining there. I went to see the chairman selection committee, a seasoned industrialist and an extremely kind gentleman, thanked him for the offer and explained why I would not be accepting it. He tried to persuade me to stay but my mind had been made up.
I spent nearly fourteen years at SICPA, extremely happy and productive years, first with Anis and then with Asif Ikram as the managing director, an ideal boss in every sense of the word. A perk of the job was at least one and sometimes two of three visits to Lausanne, Switzerland every year, the site of the company’s head office and its principal manufacturing plant. Tabana loved the country so much that our family spent many holidays there including one at Interlaken, another picturesque tourist spot.
----------
PAKISTAN
(10)
Musharraf completed seven years of power in October 2006. He had now consolidated his hold over the government, he had a prime minister of his choosing, economy was doing reasonably well and people were by and large contended. Like many Pakistani rulers preceding him however, this state of affairs was apparently not to his liking and he wanted more. The chief justice of Pakistan, Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, who had assumed this office on 30 June 2005, was proving to be not as compliant as one wished him to be. He was summoned to Musharraf’s residence, the Army House, on 9 March 2007 and told to resign in the presence of five army generals. Chaudhry refused to do so, whereby Musharraf suspended him and referred his case to the Supreme Judicial Council. Chaudhry challenged his suspension in the Supreme Court and started to tour the country addressing bar associations. On his way, he was greeted by thousands of people lining the streets and his processions began to look more like political rallies. On 20 July 2007, a thirteen-member bench of the Supreme Court reinstated Chaudhry to his position as Chief Justice. Meanwhile, Benazir Bhutto put an end to her self-exile returning back to the country in October and received jubilant welcome from people at her rally in Karachi.
Musharraf now found himself in a corner; his plan to muzzle the judiciary had backfired and he felt power slipping from his hands. On 3 November 2007, he declared a state of emergency, and suspended the constitution and the parliament. Supreme court and high court judges were asked to take a fresh oath under a provisional constitutional order but more than forty judges, including Chaudhry, refused to take this oath and were dismissed. Elections were announced to be held in February 2008 but before that, Benazir Bhutto was shot and killed by a lone gunman in Liaqat Bagh, Rawalpindi on 27 December just after she had addressed a political rally there.
Benazir’s tragic death swept Pakistan with a wave of sympathy for her party. When the elections were held, PPP won the largest number of national assembly seats (116), followed by PMLN 88 and Musharraf's PMLQ 54. At the provincial level, the PPP won in Sindh, the PML-N dominated in Punjab, Awami National Party emerged as the largest party in NWFP and PMLQ won the most seats in Baluchistan. Musharraf gracefully conceded his defeat and pledged to work with the new parliament. PPP formed a coalition government in Islamabad with MQM and Awami National Party. The new prime minister Yousuf Raza Gillani, on his first day of premiership, ordered Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry’s release from house arrest, but it took another year and only after the launch of a lawyers’ movement for restoration of judges, that Iftikhar Chaudhry was finally reinstated as the Chief Justice of Pakistan on 16 March 2009.
Through all this, Musharraf was still continuing as president though he was becoming increasingly unpopular. The matters reached a stage where PPP and PMLN agreed to force him to step down and initiate impeachment proceedings in parliament. After some resistance, Musharraf finally agreed to resign as president on 18 August 2008 and left for exile in London. He returned to Pakistan in 2013 to contest elections, but had to leave again three years later hounded by dozens of court cases against him including those for suspension of constitution, arrest of judges and conspiracy to assassinate Benazir Bhutto. He spent the rest of his life in Dubai in self-imposed exile and passed away on 5 February 2023 suffering from amyloidosis. He was laid to rest with full military honors in an army graveyard in Karachi.
---------
(11)
When Musharraf took over the reins of power in 1999, the country was still reeling under the harsh effects of economic and military sanctions imposed by America after the nuclear tests in 1998, prohibiting aid, loans and military sales. After a decade of stagnation, GDP growth had slid down to 3%. To cope with this grim scenario, a series of structural reforms were put in place during 2000 to 2007 while the U.S. Afghan war also helped to ease the burden to some extent. Investment to GDP ratio improved to 24% and foreign direct investment (FDI) rose to $5 billion in 2007. Foreign exchange reserves of State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) increased exponentially from $500 million (equal to 2 weeks imports) in 1998 to over $14 billion (5 months imports) in 2007. According to SBP statistical data, GDP growth in the 2002-07 period averaged 6.8% annually compared to 4.7% during period 1988-99.
Performance in social sectors also improved significantly. According to Dr Ishrat Husain (Governing the Ungovernable), “Poverty was reduced by 10 percentage points. The unemployment rate fell from 8.4 to 6.5 per cent and about 11.8 million new jobs were created in the FY 1999-2008 period.”
Unfortunately, the reforms and improvements in governance in this period were not sustained and, according to Dr Husain, “Some of them were reversed, halted or modified in the post-2008 period,” adversely impacting economic performance.
Unlike notable achievements on the economic front, there was mixed performance in governance and politics. National Accountability Bureau (NAB) was successful in the beginning to collect billions of rupees of ill-gotten wealth from corrupt politicians and bureaucrats, but succumbed to political expediency later when its efforts were directed towards settling old scores with opponents. Similarly, the new district government structure transferring power to elected district level administrators, though a well-planned and competently executed initiative, could not be sustained falling prey to opposition from national and provincial assembly members. One of the commendable initiatives which did survive the times was the increase in quota for women’s representation in elected bodies: 33% in local government and 17% in parliament, equal to 60 seats in national assembly and 17 in the senate.
Though trying its best, Musharraf’s government was not able to come to grips with the lop-sided political structure in Baluchistan leading to a permanent state of unrest in that province. Nawab Akbar Bugti, an ex-governor of Baluchistan, started a protest, later turning violent, against the rape of a lady doctor allegedly by an army captain, who was not prosecuted. The increasingly rebellious pronouncements by Bugti were met with force, which eventually led to his death in August 2006 when a cave where he had taken refuge blew up. In another case of ill-considered violence, a seminary housing clerics and students in Islamabad, Lal Masjid, was stormed by army troops in July 2007 after a gun fight lasting many days, resulting in deaths of over a hundred militants. The government had previously turned a blind eye towards a gradual build-up of arms cache in the seminary as well as the threatening attitude of seminary students towards people and shops in the neighborhood; acting only after some Chinese workers were kidnapped. Militants fleeing from Lal Masjid regrouped in tribal areas and formed the nucleus of armed resistance, later emerging as TTP, launched from there against the state of Pakistan.
Seeds of militancy in the tribal areas had in fact been sown much earlier in November 2001 in the closing days of American invasion. Taliban retreating from various fronts found a sanctuary in Kunduz in North-east Afghanistan. They were joined there by surviving Arab, Central Asian and Pakistani fighters, including some ISI officers and soldiers, numbering about eight thousand in all. They were surrounded on all sides by Northern Alliance commanders bitterly hostile to them. Musharraf now decided to intervene and requested President Bush for a bombing pause and opening of an air corridor to allow Pakistani aircraft to rescue his officers. Over the next three nights, more than a thousand people escaped through this route including some Taliban commanders and Arab soldiers. Unfortunately, these foreign fighters were allowed to stay in South and North Waziristan, with disastrous results for both the residents of these areas and for the Pakistan armed forces defending them for years to come.
As far as our neighbor in the East is concerned, President Musharraf had a strange “love-hate’ relationship with India throughout his career moving from frosty to warm and back again. He started the presidency with frosty relations due to his role in the 1999 Kargil adventure. It then moved towards warm when he sent a plane load of relief supplies to India after the 2001 Gujarat earthquake, followed by his first official visit to India in July 2001 meeting prime minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee. The two leaders held several rounds of one-to-one talks in Agra to try to resolve burning issues such as the decades-long Kashmir conflict and accusations of cross-border terrorism, as well as working towards jointly reducing nuclear arsenal. Though very close to a settlement, talks broke down unexpectedly due to opposition from some senior Indian cabinet members, led by deputy prime minister L.K. Advani, and Musharraf returned back home.
Only a few months after this, India and Pakistan came as close to a full-fledged war as they had ever been. There was a terrorist attack on Indian Parliament which India blamed on Pakistan and began a large-scale mobilization of troops along the border. Pakistan responded in kind but tensions were diffused after bi-lateral talks.
In 2004, Musharraf again started talks with India on the side-lines of 12th SAARC summit in Islamabad which were later continued unofficially behind the scenes but did not achieve any concrete results. There is no doubt that had the July 2001 initiative been successful, it would have brought a glorious era of peace and prosperity to the sub-continent making the lives of ordinary people of the two countries so much better.
--------